Hip or Other? Flat porch roof over an open patio — framing looks structurally separate, but the inspector marked "Other Roof." Looking for a professional second opinion

You can delete this thanks

I figured I would post a picture of the Roof in question since he mentioned my company by name

4 Likes

Customer wanted me to add the photos to this post that he took from the interior of the attic looking from the main roof to the connection point of the flat roof as well

Photo looks like “other” to me.

1 Like

delete this

OTHER roof

2 Likes

I would have marked “other” is what I’m saying.

2 Likes

right i got that part.

Aside from the shills is there anyone who can explain this with more than a 1 word answer?

It looks the flat roof portion is attached to sloped roof section (not attached to the fascia or wall).

Did you read the post or look at the 2 photos of the interior wall?

delete this

What difference does it make, both structures rely on the wall for support, the patio roof is not free standing.

If you moved the house would the patio roof stand by itself?

The inspector did his job.

4 Likes

you can delete this

ill just leave it at you are a home inspector for a reason guys.

You do realize that we know what you are talking about. We also know that rafters don’t bend, and we know roof sheeting can not be one continuous piece unless the roof is only 4 feet tall. Regardless, if wind picks up your porch roof, the house roof is going to get damaged, as I can guarantee the torch down modified bitumen is attached to the main roof under the shingles. This makes the roof system one continuous system.

The porch roof is not free standing or attached lower on the wall so the roofs would be separate systems.

To anyone not here not in Florida, the issue is how the roof shape is determined, as it relates to a specific insurance form (a form written by non-construction individuals, BTW).
The result can be a significant change in policy rates.

1 Like

What happened to “I’d appreciate an objective read from people who do these regularly”? Seems like you are more interested in finding ammunition to support your view.

5 Likes

I got a better idea…
Delete YOU!!

1 Like

Hip, Gabel, Arch, whatever. 99% of home buyers have no idea what those terms mean anyways.