Ok for boiler to have relief valve instead of expansion tank?

Is it ok for a boiler to have a relief valve instead of an expansion tank?

Also, any opinions about boiler brands? My plumber is suggesting a Penco.

Check the manufacturer’s installation instructions.

Worked on/installed a ton of Lochinvar’s back in the day. Not sure if they’re still around or made by the same company

2 Likes

In my area, they have both, and both serve separate purposes. You don’t want the boiler releasing water in a typical “expansion” event. And the relief valve is not meant to handle typical expansion events. The relief valve is a safety device for non-typical events. The expansion tank handles the normal expansion of water as it heats up.

2 Likes

Every boiler I ever installed had a relief valve, an expansion tank and an AAV. I was the High efficiency guy though. Some of the older systems didn’t have AAVs and steam systems were a different animal really. We were pulling those out mostly and flipping stuff to recirculating hot water instead of steam.

More boiler questions:

Is it ok to use Pro Press when installing a boiler, instead of soldering pipes?

Is an air separator part of the system, or is it an optional add-on?

Is a back flow prevention valve part of the system, or is it an optional add-on?

How about a low water cutoff?

If any of these are optional, should they be included?

I am not doing the work, I just want to make sure nothing is left out that should be put in.

All of that varies by Manufacturer and local AHJ.
Check with both when your Manufacturer is known.
Note: Typically Manufacturer requirements trump your local AHJ requirements, but there are always exceptions.

Propress is ok unless the MFG prohibits it’s use. I don’t know any that do, but it’s been a while since I was in that world.

Any modern system should have an air separator. I can’t imagine anything built after about 2012 that doesn’t have one but it’s equipment specific. Anything is possible I suppose.

Backflow preventers are required if the domestic water supply and auto-fill are attached.

Low water cutoff better be installed or the system will cook itself.

High-efficiency and conventional boilers have different requirements, conventional being a bit more lax as it were. A high efficiency boiler will have a primary loop to the boiler and the secondary loops to the heating zones. Connecting the two will be a separator(or closely spaced tees, but that’s mostly gone now), the separator will have an AAV. This is the only way this works. Conventional boilers have several different ways, but mostly all the water runs right through the boiler itself without going through a separator.