Today’s renovation was a 1,516 sq ft, 3/2 built in 1960. They’ve gone with an open concept but I think they didn’t do it right. My concern is the beam supporting the roof/ceiling was not properly constructed. They constructed a beam by nailing together two 2x10s and ran the span for 29’ 3". The roof was low slope so I couldn’t get into the attic to view the other end of the beam. The photos show the end of the beam near the scuttle hole (in the hall next to the kitchen cabinets), a junction box for reference that shows the load bearing wall and the corner where the kitchen cabinets are located. Other photos show the beam going off into the distance. I had to enhance the photos to take away the shadows in some of the attic photos. Other photos show the position of the beam in relation to the rest of the room (red line on the ceiling). My biggest concern, one of them at least, is where the beam is out in the middle away from two load bearing walls. (the load bearing is an assumption as I had no way to verify it). The report will indicate the questionable installation and request a review by a structural engineer or presentation of the engineering documents from the contractor that did the renovation. Any input would be appreciated.
Was there a load transfer pathway to a footing where the end of the beam by the scuttle hole sits on the wall behind the cabinets? Not sure if that would have been visible to you or not, depends on foundation type. I think you can make a fair assumption that the far end of the beam sits on an exterior wall and is transferred to a footing. As far as the span, that I don’t know. Would have to consider your local requirements for roof load.
Hey Ryan, the load appears to transfer down to the main beam directly below. The main beam runs through the crawlspace from front to rear so the beam in the attic would run almost directly above it. Part of my concern was the composition of the attic beam. From the end of the beam in the attic I could see the end of one of the 2x10s and was able to get my tape measure out and measure it. It was 10 and a half feet in length. I would be more comfortable if it wasn an LVL beam opposed to 2x10s fastened together. Of course, I’m not a carpenter or engineer so I could be way off base. Hence the post.
Anthony, did you see any anomalies to go along with your concern?
Hey Larry, I did not see any anomalies to speak of. The renovation was very recent so I don’t know if there had been sufficient time for anything to show yet. I wasn’t able to get into the attic as the roof was shallow so all my observations were from the scuttle hole at the end of beam.
I don’t understand this 10’ 6” length 2x10.
All the red lines in your pictures are longer than 10’ 6”.
Where is the 2 x 10 x 10’ 6” that you would be happier if it was a LVL beam?
Hey Larry, I was afraid it would be confusing. As I was on the ladder in the scuttle hole I could look and see that the beam was composed of two 2x10s (4x10) screwed together. The whole length of the composed beam is ~30 ft (29 ft 3 in). As I looked down the length of the beam I could see where one of the 2x10s composing the beam ended and then another 2x10 began. The length of that 2x10 was 10.5 feet. So I know that one portion of this 4x10 beam is made up of a 10.5 ft 2x10. In my mind, 30ft is a long span for a composed beam.
Hey Larry, the red lines in the photos are an attempt to show the location of the beam, not to dictate length. I should have said that when I posted.
Anthony, it does seem like quite a length for a pieced built up double 2x10 beam.
What was the beam supporting? Was the bean glued and screwed or bolted?
Was there any plans available since it was recent as you say?
Hey Larry, maybe this video will help. The beam was supporting a low slope roof. It was screwed together and I didn’t see any signs of glue. Plans? No plans in sight.
Yes, that does help.
I’d refer that out just by its own weight at that span, let alone any added carrying load.
Heck, the loaded weight of the nm cables on top of that bean is enough to question that built up beam’s integrity. ![]()
Morning, Anthony. Hope to find you well.
Seeing floor joists can cantilever in two directions relative to their layout: parallel or perpendicular could this be perpendicular cantalverer?
I think the “beam” is being supported by multiple cantilevered ceiling joists at both ends. Interesting is that the ceiling joists look to be 2x6 construction (stronger than normal) and everything, including the rafters and wiring, does not look 66 years old.
Here is my hunch. For some reason, this portion of the entire roof structure was replaced and instead of ordering a set of engineered trusses to fit the span, they decided to build a conventional stick-built roof from wood acquired from the local store. However, they could not obtain continuous lengths of wood that would cover the entire span, so they improvised.
It is perfectly fine to have ceiling joists that lap in order to cover a span. However, the lap area needs to be of good size with dozens of fasteners (for strength) and be fully supported by load bearing wall(s) and/or beam(s), not joist hangers. These joists do not overlap thereby creating a weak joint, are not fully supported and, where there is some support, they are cantilevered by a fair amount. Poor design all around.
I do not think the ceiling (or roof) is going to fall down. However, it is likely to flex, loosening and/or cracking the drywall at the joint over time.
It is unlikely that any structural engineer signed off on the design, so recommending that the client ask for the finalized building permit and design documents is the absolute right call.
It would take a large multiply LVL to support a ceiling and roof over the distance suggested. Was this renovation under a building permit? If not, l would state the roof framing was not fully accessible for inspection. If the ceiling or ridge line had visible sag then suggest further evaluation by a structural engineer. Typically a low slope roof your photo indicated would require a ridge beam with intermediate supports at some interior load bearing walls.
Thanks everyone for the input. I wrote hard on this one and recommended obtaining permits and engineering documentation. I suspect it’ll all be for naught though. There had to have been a hundred different types of biological growths in the crawlspace. The floor joists supporting that big empty area in the middle of the floor contained moisture according to the meter. There was mold, I mean, there was biological growth Everywhere. In hindsight I should have been wearing a mask throughout the inspection. The floor grill for the return was larger than the return duct, so there was a space between the duct and the flooring that opened up to the crawlspace. So all that wonderful crawlspace are was circulating throughout the house. Wonderful.
When I see this kind of stuff, I recommend checking for permits, and if no permit is found, I recommend getting a structural engineer to look at it.
Trying to figure out if it’s legit or not is way beyond our scope.
But also, I’m in California, where home inspectors are not allowed by law to do anything that would be considered an engineer’s practice. (BPC § 7196.1)











