"And yet I feel obliged to withhold my approval of the plan, as proposed by this bill, to indulge a benevolent and charitable sentiment through the appropriation of public funds for that purpose.
I can find no warrant for such an appropriation in the Constitution, and I do not believe that the power and duty of the General Government ought to be extended to the relief of individual suffering which is in no manner properly related to the public service or benefit. A prevalent tendency to disregard the limited mission of this power and duty should, I think, be steadfastly resisted, to the end that the lesson should be constantly enforced that though the people support the Government the Government should not support the people."
Great quote. How amazing to hear politically unpopular principled thinking and clear judgement from an American president just a little more than 100 years ago. There should be a documentary/tragi-comedy made, outlining the history of our federal government’s spread, and titled “A prevalent tendency”.
Grover Cleveland was president before the Democratic party started pandering for votes. Now they’ll promise you anything if you’ll just vote for them! It’s the only way they can get elected.
So which entitlements would you do away with Nick?
Social Security?
Medicare?
Medicade?
ACA/Obamacare?
Foodstamps?
Unemployment benefits?
Veterans Benefits?
Federal and Military retirement programs?
FEMA? By proxy it is an entitlement.
I think it safe to say that most of the members currently are or have in the past needed and used these programs.
I would really like to see a balanced budget and start paying down the debt, but fat chance of that happening any time soon.
I would also prefer to see the rich and corporations pay their fair share in taxes as a percentage of money made.
I also would prefer that they not only get the money out of politics, including lobbying, but also Congress & the SCOTUS should all have term limits, gerrymandering should be against the law, and abolish the electoral college, one person, one vote.
IMO that would be a good start, but again, fat chance that any of that will ever happen.
Social Security is the big one. It’s a scam. And there are no reserves, bureaucrats stole and spent all the Social Security reserves. And the payout is abysmal, many times less than even the most conservative investment. And the payout formula is very racist. Shut it down now.
Shut it down. Refund everyone’s money with interest (we’ll all get a check for millions), apologize to the American people, and promise to never try to manage our money again.
There is no such thing as “Unemployment benefits.” There is unemployment insurance. Insurance isn’t a benefit, it’s a product we were forced to buy. Allow us to buy it from private insurance companies so that we have a choice between competing insurance providers.
FEMA is unconstitutional and theft. The federal government has no business taking our money and then returning a small portion of it during a disaster. That is theft. And unconstitutional. Read what Grover Cleveland said. FEMA is an illegal operation. Remember, they are the criminals, not us.
I would actually increase veteran benefits for those who honor their oath to uphold the Constitution. I would eliminate them for those who do not, including the pesky part about needing a Declaration of War from Congress before waging war. Give everyone a year or so advance notice so that those thinking about going into the service can make an informed decision and eliminate all court marshal risk for upholding the Constitution in the face of an illegal order. We want to reward those servicemen and women who disobey unconstitutional orders. That seems fair.
As for retirements, we can not take those away. Those are part of the compensation we offered people to take those jobs and we have to honor those commitments.
Foodstamps don’t add up to squat and so I’m fine with them. Pennies compared to Ponzi scams like Social Security.
I don’t know enough about Obamacare, medicare or medicade to have an opinion.
You both left the most important part of my statement out of the quote.
I have nothing against the rich or corporations making as much money as they possibly can, but I have everything against the rich and corporations being able to manipulate loopholes in the tax code (thanks to lobbyists) to lower their tax burden percentage wise considerably lower than the average American. Get rid of the loopholes, which incidentally I also use, just not to the extent of Billionaires or large corporations.
Say a wealthy person makes $10 million and would pay $3 million in taxes. But instead, he buys 1 million red hats with a slogan on them from China for $500,000. Then he sells 100 of those hats for $20 each, which brings in $2000 and establishes a street value of $20 per hat. Then he donates the remaining 999,900 hats to charity for a loss of $20 x 999,900 = $19,998,000.
So his business made $10 million, then spent $500,000 on hats of which it sold 100 for an income of $2000, and donated the rest for a loss of $19,99800. So he walks away with $10 million - $500,000 + $2000 = $9,502,000 in his pocket but pays no tax since the year was a loss.
Why would you do that? Remember, every “loophole” LOWERS the taxes corporations pay, it doesn’t raise them! Lowering corporate taxes is the same as lowering the cost of living for the poor, because corporate taxes are regressive taxes on the poor. Read: www.gromicko.com/corporate
Of course they do. They are stupid and believe that when the expenses to produce products and services go up… that prices don’t. That’s beyond stupid, actually. That’s super stupid. When you increase a company’s costs with higher rent, higher utilities, or higher taxes, those costs HAVE TO be passed on to their customers. Don’t try to fool me. You aren’t stupid
THERE IS NO TRUTH TO THAT! That U.S. Tax Code doesn’t know what anyone’s net worth is. It can’t charge rich people less because it doesn’t know who is rich. You’ve done your taxes before, do you recall any question about your net worth? Nope. It’s all based on income. That’s why it is called “income tax.” Nothing in the U.S. tax code is based off of wealth. And the tax code charges higher incomes a greater percent in taxes. We have a progressive tax system.
Maybe they are talking about effective tax rate? If that’s what they mean then they were disingenuous with the title of their article. That should make you suspicious about the rest of the article. Anyway, if that is what they meant to say, it might be true but not because we charge them less taxes on their income. We charge them MORE. Again, we have a progressive tax based on income, not wealth.
When the income tax was first proposed and adopted, it was only to apply to the ultra wealthy. That’s how they got stupid poor people to support it: “Yeah, tax the rich!” Now the stupid poor people working for minimum wage pay income tax.
It worked once, so the government is trying it again. They want a wealth tax that will only apply to the ultra wealthy. And again, stupid poor people are supporting it: “Yeah, tax the rich!” And again, the stupid poor people will one day be paying tax on the appreciation of their double-wide trailers every year.
It proves my theory: Our capitalist system isn’t fueled by greed, it’s fueled by envy.
Do you invest as much back into the economy in terms of jobs or manufacturing? How much do you actually have onvested? That is one of the “loopholes.” We all know the government wastes more than it invests. So essentially you believe the rich should waste more money than you. Are you willing to pay the same percentage of your income?