I’ll start with question one. What are we verifying there? What is the definition of “structure”?
The question should read: Year built: xxxx
And that is all. By answering that question, you are verifying just that, the year built. Let the insurance companies determine if it is code compliant, which, if everything went correctly, should be based on the permit date, which either they can go find, or we can.
I can go on, but I think you get my point.
If the OiR wants us to document things, give us specific things to document.
On Q1, I use the YB, but if around the cut off date, I also include the original build application date. Everything changed when the FBC started. I remember this…plan review checked everything before permit was issued and took forever. On a recent WM, I had the house with a YB of 2004 (CO date), but when checking the permit, it was applied for in Jan of 2002…Non-FBC. It makes a difference sometimes.
It makes a difference the other way as well. I have had homes that were permitted prior to 9/1/94, that had single wraps, 8D nails six inches apart, and the materials used that had noa numbers that were accepted.
The home was built in 96 and permitted in august 94.
Although everything indicated it was compliant with the 94 code, still no discount for question one or 2. And it isn’t just one house. I know several homes especially in Pembroke Pines, entire developments in fact, that were permitted prior to 9/1/94 yet by all appearances, were built using that code.
It would be my opinion, due to the wording of the 1802, that it is a code inspection or at least a verification of a code inspection. I wonder, if this case isn’t reversed on appeals, if the inspector will also be charged for operating out of the scope of his license as he isn’t a building official.
As far as I can tell, the ruling was just hyped up in the media. It has to do with separate discounts for reinforced garage doors, filed by a garage door company. NON EVENT, but I do think the next form will include small discounts for properly protected garage doors by themselves.
Secure Enterprises v. Office of Insurance Regulation and Financial Services Commission, DOAH 12-1944RX
Bill, your posts are delayed for some time. I don’t see them most of the time until later on. Sorry about that. Maybe you can clear that up with NACHI.
Wrong case. That was back in 2012> This case has no press that I know of as of today. The ruling was, as I stated, that the 1802 is a code compliant inspection.
Eric, I cannot give you the case number. This information was given to me in confidence and we were given some, but not all of the details. I can tell you it was a recent ruling, and the process is still ongoing. I will keep you up to date as I learn more.
That is for the non hurricane zone.
The thinking being, that as Brad pointed out, everything was supposed to be in order and if the house was built in 2004 or later, it should have a permit application date after 3/1/02.
That isn’t always the case and in numerous instances in the hurricane zone, it isn’t either.
As Meeker said, my posts are delayed because I am a non member. That will not change. Guess they want to closely monitor me. Some of my responses have been censored. Go figure that, but they let Meeker run amok on a public board
mmaizel
(Marvin Maizel, CMI® Fl State Lic HI 681)
33
It is the date the permit was issued. That verifies under which code the structure was built.
The building inspector can only use the permitted drawings.
If a new code was enacted after this one was permitted…He can only go by the original permitted drawings.
Year built is usually the CO date. Use what the property appraiser site says for the Q1 box. If YB is 2002-2003, also list the original application date for the permit. The application date is what determines FBC compliance, not YB.
Date of CO is different from the permit application date. A house could be CO’d in 1996, but the application date could be in 1994 before 9/1. The CO does not tell you what code reference to use, the application date does.