Did a wind mitigation yesterday and wrote down this home has having SWR. Looking back at the picture I started questioning if it was. I usually do a ruler test but can’t remember if I did. The homeowner was talking to me throughout the inspection so I’m afraid I may not have. Does this look like SWR?
It doesn’t look “shiny” in that tiny picture, but you need to confirm with a business card or similar. How old is the roof system?
Aged SWR is no longer very sticky due to exposure to dust & air.
Did you look around vents or penetrations? Way easier to see the underlayment in those areas.
And your client was taking to you while you were in the attic? Tighten up your inspection protocols, missing important items will take its toll.
It was a brand new roof and was replaced to improve their SWR. They did have swr installed they said but my main concern is that it was in fact done on top the old roof. Old permit info says their old roof was done that way. This was a walk-in attic (partially livable and can’t see sheathing)so he followed. I’ve asked the homeowner for invoice info but they haven’t responded. The photo doesn’t look shiny to me either so thats why I questioned what I wrote down. I’ll probably call the homeowner later today for more info.
Then they don’t have a qualifying SWR.
It must be a self-adhered product, installed directly to the sheathing or decking, not on top on an old roof.
You’re right but thats the old roofing permit that was installed by putting the new shingles on the old. The new permit doesn’t state anything other than re-roof. I just grew concern when seeing the one before this new one was installed that way. Do you know if a permit ever says “re-roof” if they do install over existing shingles? I’ve only seen it listed as a “roof alteration”
In my area of Central Florida, a re-roof is a total tear-off.
About 1 in 10,000 roofs are installed on top of an old layer.
Most AHJ’s don’t like seeing that type of install and will question it, and most roofers don’t even offer it (for several valid reasons).
Got it, I was thinking the same thing. I’ll still follow up and get with the homeowner to be sure before marking it as anything. Thanks for the help.
SWR can not be verified by a photo. It will either list it in the online permit information, on the permit packet that is left behind, or you will need to call the roofing company to obtain the information. If you obtain it through the roofer make sure they email it to you so you have a paper trail. It really doesn’t make that big of a difference though, as it is the smallest discount they can get. The only time it is somewhat significant is when it is for an HOA that just had new roofs installed and their insurance is $1.5M +, then it is a significant difference.
In Florida, a Secondary Water Resistance (SWR) credit should only be given when there is verifiable documentation, such as a roofing permit, product approval, contract, or affidavit that specifically states SWR was installed. While photos can help support a finding, they are not sufficient by themselves to confirm SWR.
Many roofing materials and underlayments can look similar in attic or installation photos, and without permit documentation, there’s no reliable way to confirm the system meets the SWR requirement under OIR guidelines. When documentation isn’t available, the correct and defensible approach is to mark SWR as “Unknown or Not Determined”
