Radon Pump vs Mitigation

In Minnesota, passive systems are required, meaning the pipe is installed with penetration through the roof. A receptacle is provided within the attic space, so adding an inline fan and turning the system into an active approach is always an option. Passive systems will still help depressurize beneath the slab and help with radon (probably in this case)

Roughly 150,000 people die yearly from Lung cancer (this is higher from the 2022 estimate). This number varies annually, but from the data I’ve been able to get from the American Lung Association, I think it’s a reasonable rough estimate.

According to cancer.gov, scientists estimate that roughly 15,000 to 22,000 lung cancer deaths yearly in the United States are related to Radon.

Of the 15,000 to 22,000 lung cancer deaths yearly associated with Radon, roughly 10% are among non-smokers. Meaning approximately 1,500 to 2,200 lung cancer deaths annually among non-smokers in the United States are related to Radon Exposure (according to epa.gov this number is 2900). If we’re to take the high end of that, that means Radon Exposure alone accounts for roughly 1.5 percent of lung cancer deaths a year.

My point here is not to say that Radon cannot pose a health risk in some circumstances, but rather the situation is much more complex than often presented. Each individual should consider their own lifestyle choices to make an informed decision on how to proceed. Whether or not Radon is present in high levels, Radon Mitigation can often provide benefits outside of reducing radon levels, such as its ability to reduce humidity levels throughout your home (particularly in older construction).

And so no, its not equivalent to smoking a pack of cigarettes a day.

I posted the photos of a defective radon mitigation system above (btw - I am certified by the NRPP as a ASD Compliance Inspector) to hopefully provide a learning experience for my fellow InterNACHI Inspectors. For some reason, the peanut gallery feels the need to chime in on just about anything except the obviously major defect I presented. The somewhat dismissive attitude conveyed does not serve your customers well and could very well create a liability issue for you down the road.

From the NRPP FAQ page - How much radon is too much?
Radon is a radioactive gas and there is no safe level. Consumers should be aware that U.S. EPA’s estimate of 21,000 annual deaths from radon induced lung cancer in the U.S. was based on an average level of 1.3 picocuries per liter of air. The EPA Action Level of 4 picocuries/per liter of air (pCi/L) was based on the achievability of early radon mitigation technology from three decades ago. Annual exposure to 4 pCi/l is the equivalent of 200 chest x-rays per year. The World Health Organization recommends indoor radon should not exceed 100 Bq/m3 (Becquerel per cubic meter) which equates to 2.7 pCi/L. Lung cancer risk rises 16% per 2.7 pCi/L increase in radon exposure. Homeowners/Buyers - FAQs - NRPP

From Smoking and Radon Exposure | Causes of Lung Cancer

Radon is the number one cause of lung cancer among non-smokers, and the second leading cause of lung cancer overall. It is responsible for approximately 20,000 lung cancer deaths each year. Nearly 3,000 of these deaths occur in never-smokers. The risk for smokers increases exponentially the higher the Radon levels.

My point here is that no one deserves lung cancer and as someone in a position to potentially prevent someone from getting it as a result of long term exposure to Radon, Home Inspectors should really be placing more emphasis with regard to presenting the risks when any Radon is present.

CDC
“In the United States, about 10% to 20% of lung cancers, or 20,000 to 40,000 lung cancers each year, happen in people who never smoked or smoked fewer than 100 cigarettes in their lifetime.”

Very different data from CDC.

1 Like

According to the US EPA, that is now considered reason enough to test the basement.
Interesting, would love to see the reference from the EPA on that.

Also, was the laundry facilities down there?
Any other reasons that someone may be in the basement for more than a very short visit?
Maintenance services?
As I said. . .it’s used for storage. . .would you consider that “occupied?
According to the ANSI/AARST MAH 2019 for time sensitive testing, the test should be conducted in the lowest level that could be occupied. Extended testing protocol states that the test should be conducted in the lowest level that is occupied. The standard goes on to say that it is best to choose locations where people are most likely to spend time. Can’t say that I envision people spending time in their basement storeroom.

People need to stay current with their information
Yes they do!!

1 Like

All those stored items didn’t get down there by themselves… and huffing and puffing after lugging it all down there sure won’t help their situation any!!

Bet ya all their Holiday Decorations are down there too!

1 Like

The EPA uses the ANSI/AARST MAH 2019 (if there is a newer version, I have not found it)
Based on my interpretation, I would have tested the basement.

4 Likes

What was the sq footage and ceiling height of the basement? I have ran into a few basements where I opted to test the main floor instead. But those are typically when the basement is very, very small, generally in poor condition, and with very low ceilings that would likely prohibit the chance of spending much time down there.

Growing up, my brothers and I were usually sent to our unfinished basement to play rather than annoy our parents upstairs. We spent hours and hours down there per a week, especially in the winter.

2 Likes

What do you guys think of this house we had on Friday? The basement has a pool and a bathroom. Nothing else.
This is not living space but they might spend a lot of time down there with the kids playing.

I told my guy to test one floor up where the living room and kitchen and one of the bedrooms is. I didn’t consider the pool to be living space. But Brian’s post has me reconsidering the definition of living space that I have been using.

What do you think?


3 Likes

Without a doubt i would have tested the basement. Was this a full basement under the entire home? In MN we are required to test each foundation type separately. So if a house has a crawl under part of it, and basement under the rest, I would need to test in the basement (assuming I considered it livable), and on the floor above the crawl. The client would get two reports.

2 Likes

I may be in the peanut gallery, but I do not see anyone being dismissive. In fact, it appears to me some very experienced and qualified inspectors are chiming in.

I find the basement conversation to be of importance to help everyone learn something.

So, that brings up this: You obviously did a short-term test above the basement level.

So, based on your own submission, this was worthy of discussion.

3 Likes

I would have tested the pool basement. Radon levels tend to concentrate in sub-terranean spaces and this space would be occupied often.

3 Likes

I will update my definition of living space. Thanks for the quick response. We help each other be better inspectors.

3 Likes

At the risk of sounding nonchalant, all information is important. This chart offers some perspective. I would never tell a client not to mitigate elevated levels of radon, but we can stay calm and deliberate.

The risk chart is based on “Lifetime Exposure”

3 Likes

And then there’s this, lol…

1 Like

So, do we get into the “Radon in Water” discussion now?? :wink:

4 Likes

Admittedly I know little. My understanding this issue is mostly a result of well water or water not aeriated. Municipal water supplies are almost always “pre-aeriated” and not an issue. In Atlanta, it comes from lakes. What is the story in your area?

Rural Minnesota… damned near everyone away from a small town, (which are typically spaced 15+ miles apart), is on a Private Well system!

Gee, I wonder where all the irrigation water (pumped out of the earth) for the crops (ie. corn, soybeans, etc..) deposits it’s Radon particulates?

2 Likes

Good call! (thought I would support your protocol for others)

image

2 Likes

Hey Bert, here is a bit more information from the same source I mentioned above.

image

I use SunRadon 1028 XP

2 Likes

Yeah, the numbers vary from year to year. As I mentioned, some of my data was pulled from varying years.

My intent was not to indicate whether it was a problem or not, and my intent was not to indicate that it is not indeed a contributor to lung cancer. Simply stating it is the 2nd leading cause, in my belief, is a tad intellectually dishonest without providing context, such as the significant difference between smokers and non-smokers, as well as the significant difference in numbers between the high estimates and the total deaths associated with lung cancer.

1 Like