roof

I guess with my experience with cedar shakes and shingles, I have to agree with statements by Raymond Wand.

If one looks at all the newer installations of cedar shakes today as recommended by Manufactureres, you will see the link to comparisons of installation to 18th Century style.

Methods have changed slightly, but are still on the same principal of the old planking system that would let the shakes dryout from the attic space.

Marcel :slight_smile: :slight_smile:
</IMG></IMG>

I don’t believe I said that one was better than the other. What I really asked for was some documentation. We don’t install wood roofs here anymore, so I would find such documentation interesting since I haven’t read up on it recently since I don’t have to do inspect new wood roofs.

Well, duh! I have no problem witih spaced planking. In fact, we used to always do it that way in Texas when I was doing roofs in the '70s and '80s. Saved money, which, ultimately, is what it’s all about. What I do have a problem with is a generalized statement that wood roofs last longer with one method over another method. I do find it interesting that you were for spaced planking but then took the double-negative position that the building code "does not indicate that spaced planking is not allowed, seeming to indicate that I had said that spaced planking is not allowed. I’m not familiar with anything anywere that says spaced planking is not allowed, regardless of what type of roof it is. I have seen manufacturer’s installation instructions stating that it is not recommended for specific installations, like some of our heaviest concrete tiles here in high-fire-hazard-country.

Knowing how something was done well into the past does not necessarily make one an expert at the reasons why it was done, or not done as the case may be. It simply makes one an expert at what was done well into the past. One could certainly argue that if something done a hundred years ago was the best way, all things considered, then we would still be doing it that way.

So while the sites posted in the previous posts are good, I’m still not reading any documentation that supports your statements.

Then don’t believe me. You seem to be the proverbial fountain of knowledge. If you read the links you would find the answers.

Nope. Just always questioning and always trying to find and provide answers.

I did, but I didn’t find anything that documented your statement that spaced planking caused a roof to last longer. I would like to read the research; I think it would be interesting. I grew up as a researcher and still do a lot of research.

Since we don’t do wood roofs here, researching them is not going to be at the top of my list of things to do. Since you sound so knowledgable, I thought you might have some good documentation supporting your statement. Apparently you don’t.

Russel

… and if you don’t do wood roofs there, then your question is irrelevent. Otherwise look up the info yourself! No one else seems to have problem with it other than you.

Wow. I sure hope you don’t treat your Clients like that. I can see it now:

“Well, Mr. Client. No one else has ever asked me that question, so it must be irrelevant. So look it up yourself. No one else seems to have had a problem other than you.” :wink:

So all I can assume is that you don’t like being helpful or that you don’t have supporting documentation.

Get over yourself! :wink:

Having a bad day, Ray? Ms Margarita can help. :mrgreen:

rray;

Not that I am taking sides, but as we all know, back in the 1940’s to the late 1950’s, it was common for spaced planking because that is all that was available.

When cedar shingles were starting to fade out to the onset of the new Product called “Asbestos Asphalt Compound Shingles”, everyone was wild. They “the people” started substituting the cedar shingles for asphalt shingles and co-incidentally installed over the substrate material that was there, which in this case was spaced boards that came from a saw mill run by water and not sized for width to save money, therefore you had the automatic gaps that we are talking about.

Today’s standard for ventilation kind of reads down this line,

*There are two very important questions that must be asked of, and answered by, every construction design-whether it is for new construction, for additions or for renovations: *
*1. How does heat enter the attic, and how can those heat sources be reduced?
2. How does heat exit the attic?**The rule of thumb is that properly vented attic air should never be more than 15 degrees hotter than the outside air. A temperature difference of greater than 15 degrees is an indication of additional heat sources that should be eliminated and/or an indication of poor attic ventilation. *
*Proper attic ventilation is calculated by comparing the ratio of attic floor space to the total amount of “net free air ventilation area.” The most beneficial ratio is 1/150; that is 1 SF of net free air ventilation for every 150 SF of attic floor space. All ventilation sold for this purpose has an assigned “net free air” square footage rating that is roughly the total opening size of the vent, minus the various areas of block-age from louvers and screens. Ideally, the total of inlet air at the soffit will equal the outlet air at the ridge for a balanced and efficient airflow. *

*Figure for a moment of the construction of past buildings with spaced planking and how it was used and no ventilation in the attic. *
**
*Guess what, Most houses back then had walk-in cold attics for storage, and had vented windows or non-vented sashes for natural light. *
*Since the windows were of single pane and no weather seal, a draft would come in the attic. You could also see the gaps around the chimney flashings and feel the breeze. *
*You could observe the new asphalt shingles or cedar shingles from the attic and also feel the breeze from the exterior wind. *
The gable end walls were constructed of vertical boards and spaces and you could see the black homeasote or celitex board with brick imitation, and could feel the breeze from the end walls.

Run the mathematics and calculations of all the free air coming in to the attic in this era of building and you will find the it most likely exceed the requirement that I have provided above of today’s standard.

This is why that the roofing on my Father’s House lasted for over 35 years without replacement.

Raymond Wand is not off track at all with his statements, but rather you can not relate to the existence of the past Construction techniques, and no one has written a book on this subject that I can find to show you or refer to as Raymond indicated. This is based on observance and past experience with this type of Construction.

It is hard to relate and compare to today’s standards.

Marcel :slight_smile: :slight_smile: :wink:
**
**

</IMG></IMG></IMG>

Huh?

I thought we were discussing spaced planking versus full planking. I’m not familiar with anything that says one is any better than the other. If there is something out there, I would enjoy reading it.

We used spaced planking when I was doing roofing in Texas in the 1970s and 1980s because we could do two houses of spaced planking for the same cost as one house of full planking. That’s a no-brainer to me.

I have no problem relating to past construction techniques. I grew up in a large, poor family where we built everything ourselves. And I’ve continued to be a builder throughout my life. But broad, general, summary statements like Raymond made demand questions and answers. I’ve asked the questions (where’s the documentation) but so far no one has provided any answers (no documentation), which means that there probably isn’t any actual emperical evidence that one method is any better than the other method.

So, all things considered, the only thing I can see that spaced planking does versus full planking is save money on planks.

RR quote"We used spaced planking when I was doing roofing in Texas in the 1970s and 1980s because we could do two houses of spaced planking for the same cost as one house of full planking. That’s a no-brainer to me" So you are saying that exactly 1/2 of the two homes roofs was just space??:roll: That is a lot of space, </IMG>

Russel

You show how little you actually know. Planking costs considerably more to use, and more time consuming to install, that is why it is not used. Does spaced planking breath better, yes it does particularly with wood shingles. Does it help aphalt shingle on space plank breath or keep cooler, that is the theory because it is not solid, allowing for some air movement on the underside as opposed to solid plank decking or plywood which would be less so because there is no space.

Sorry you are having a hard time with this matter. Marcel raised very good points as have others. You don’t seem to be familiar with a lot of things except yourself.

Absolutely right Ray!

Solid wood roof planking is more expensive to purchase and more labour intensive to install. I have worked on houses with both. Solid wood planking also makes for a stronger roof deck than most plywood or OSB being used today. Rafter spacing is typically 16" OC for 3/4" thick boards and the 1/2"
to 1" gap between the boards provides for expansion and aids with heat dissipation in summer. This is why some of these roofs are still around after 100 years. With proper roof maintenance they can last much longer than that.

My 2 cents.:roll:

Roy Richards
Master Carpenter
Home Builder and Renovator

Yes.

All the wood roofs out here that I have seen also use spaced planking, what we called in Texas “skip sheathing,” i.e., we skip every other board/plank. That saves money. And since wood is lightweight, one didn’t need the full sheathing.

Two things changed that in the roofing industry: composition and tile roofs and inexpensive plywood/OSB/chipboard/fiberboard. Now it is much easier and less expensive because of labor to simply install full sheathing via 4x8 plywood or OSB. Again, a no-brainer. Labor costs are high whereas the product itself is cheap. That’s why property investors/flippers put sweat equity into the properties. The only way to reduce the cost of the product is to buy in bulk quantities and to buy at sales. Labor cost is labor cost, and while there is some leeway and negotiation for the total cost of the job, which might include cost-of-labor reduction, the easiest way to save money is to do it oneself to save labor costs. In the olden days, all things considered (not including slavery, of course), labor costs were still a significant part of any building project. So installing skip sheathing was valuable because it reduced both hard costs (one only needed half as many planks) and labor costs (it only cost half as much to install half as many planks).

Since I have a bachelor’s degree in Forest Management with emphasis in organic chemistry, wood engineering, structural engineering, and civil engineering, I would really be interested in any documentation that anyone can provide stating that any specific roof installation provides greater longevity over any other specific roof installation. To the best of my knowledge, its the ventilation in the attic itself that assists in roof longevity. And I can tell you from my own research experience that using, say, one inch plywood, or one inch OSB, or one inch full-sheath planks, or one inch-space planks is not going to have any statistically significant effect on roof longevity. Where they have an effect is in structural engineering. A one-inch full sheathed roof will have significantly greater engineering capacity than a one-inch skip-sheathed roof. That’s why, when wood roofs are replaced with comp or tile, it is necessary to remove the skip-sheathing and install full sheathing.

So, with my lifelong interest in wood, wood engineering, and organic chemistry, I wait with bated breath for documentation concerning this topic.

See my previous post.

You show how little you understand wood, wood engineering, and the insulative properties of wood.

That’s the labor costs that I discussed previously, which is the reason why spaced planking was used over solid planking, not because of any perceived value concerning insulation or roof longevity.

So have I. I also have education in wood, wood engineering, etc. See my previous post.

The key word in that sentence is “most.”

When plywood and OSB first hit the market, they definitely were weak. Most (key word “most” again) higher grade plywood and OSB can match most (key word “most” again) solid lumber of the same size as far as engineering strength for the same use. And depending on the type of tree used for the solid lumber, many plywood and OSB grades exceed their engineering strength. Plywood and OSB are wonderful materials, making use of what otherwise might have been discarded in the olden days but using today’s glues and structural engineering empirical evidence can provide excellent engineered materials at much less cost.

That’s the research documentation that I’m looking for and which apparently doesn’t exist. Also see my previous post.

And as I tell my Clients, here in San Diego, with proper roof maintenance, a 5-year roof can last 20 years, a 10-year roof can last 40 years, etc. However, without proper roof maintenance, a 5-year roof can also last 11 months. In fact, I had an inspection a couple of years ago where I stated that the roof was past the end of its useful life. The seller was furious because he had a receipt showing the new 10-year roof was put on only two years ago. The roof burned up because of lack of ventilation (see picture). The roofing company and the manufacturer refused to honor the warranty because of homeowner abuse.

RoofBurn.jpg

Russel,

Here is your documentation.

How to Build A wood-Frame House
L.O. Anderson
Engineer
Forest Products Laboratory, Forest Services
U.S. Department of Agriculture

Dover Publications, Inc
New York

Prove that.

Prove that.

Prove that.

Prove that. You say it doesn’t exist based on your own perception and lack of knowledge. Yet we have had several experienced inspectors state otherwise, you are unwilling to accept experience as a fact.

Also while your at it get a copy of Canadian Wood Frame House Construction and the Ontario Building Code and the info provided by the Canadian Wood Council, also ask other roofers and inspectors who are familiar with century homes constructed in Ontario.

Quote from the Canadian Wood Frame House Construction.