Grab Your Checkbooks - For sale: 2 million empty homes

For sale: 2 million empty homes

Number of vacant homes on the market nationwide equivalent to all homes in Detroit; another sign of weak housing market.

By Chris Isidore, senior writer
October 26 2007: 12:13 PM EDT

NEW YORK ( – The number of vacant homes for sale rose in the third quarter, according to the latest government reading that casts new harsh light on the weakness of the housing market.

The Census Bureau report puts the number of vacant homes for sale at 2.07 million in the period, up about 2 percent from the second quarter, and 7 percent above year ago levels.

In another sign of the weak housing market, the number of vacant homes for sale rose in the third quarter.

The number is down 5 percent from the record high reading reached in the first quarter, though.

For purposes of comparison for the current situation, imagine the Detroit metropolitan area, which the Census Bureau estimated had 2.08 million households in its 2000 Census. Now picture virtually every house or condo empty, with a for sale sign in the front yard of every home, from inner-city Detroit to its suburbs, all the way to nearby cities such as Flint and Ann Arbor.

There are always some homes vacant and for sale, even in a booming real estate market.

But the combination of overbuilding by home builders in the middle of the decade and problems in mortgage markets this year that made it more difficult for buyers to get the financing they needed to buy a home has swelled the inventory of vacant homes on the market.

Because the mortgage market meltdown has thinned the ranks of potential home buyers some home owners have been forced to move out of homes before they can find a buyer. And those who bought homes or condos as investments during the real estate and building booms of a couple of years ago have found an exceptionally weak market for their property. That in turn has lifted the number of vacant homes for sale by 57 percent in just the last three years. And some see the situation only getting worse.

New home sales: Bad, and worse than they seem

“It’s really striking how high that is compared to historic levels,” said Dean Baker, co-founder of the Center for Economic and Policy Research. “It’s a lot of homes sitting there vacant. It’s very hard to see how we’re near a bottom, when you have that much excess supply.”

Baker said that the owners trying to sell the vacant homes are going to be very motivated sellers, since it’s difficult to carry the cost of a home that isn’t having any use. That will drive down home prices and values for all homeowners. And he said that the problem is likely to get far worse as the problems in the mortgage markets could cause problems if foreclosures increase as expected.

There are estimates that about 2.8 million homeowners could see the payments on their subprime mortgages reset higher in the next two years. If they can’t afford the new payments or be able to refinance due to the significantly tighter mortgage market, that could cause an additional flood of empty homes onto the market.

“It’s very hard to see how this doesn’t get worse,” Baker said. “It’s certainly possible we could see 3 million, maybe 4 million (vacant homes on the market.)”

Existing home sales: Historic weakness

Friday’s report is just the latest in a series of readings showing weakness in the nation’s real estate market.

Wednesday the National Association of Realtors reported that the pace of sales of existing single family homes fell to the lowest level since 1998 in September. Its reading for the sales rate for all existing homes, including condos and other multi-family units, was the lowest since it started tracking those sales in 1999.

Thursday a separate Census Bureau report showed the pace of new home sales fell to an 11-year low in August, as it revised lower its earlier estimate for sales that month and for July. The September sales pace of new homes was a touch higher than August, but some experts questioned that estimate given the report of a jump in sales in the West.

The rising delinquency and default rates that caused a meltdown in the mortgage market led Countrywide Financial (Charts, Fortune 500), the nation’s leading mortgage lender, to report a $1.2 billion net loss Friday that was far larger than forecasts. And the glut of new homes available for sale has hammered the results of the nation’s leading builders.

On Wednesday, Pulte Homes (Charts, Fortune 500) reported a much bigger than expected loss in the most recent quarter. Ryland Homes (Charts, Fortune 500) also reported a loss, while rival Centex disclosed that it had cut prices on some homes by 15 to 20 percent in order to try to maintain sales, as well as cutting staff by more than 40 percent. The day before Centex (Charts, Fortune 500) had reported a large second quarter loss.

Home builders: Worst is yet to come

In addition, leading home builder D.R. Horton (Charts, Fortune 500) reported last week that its fiscal fourth-quarter orders fell 39 percent, while the value of those orders plunged 48 percent. Credit rating agency Moody’s downgraded the debt of Pulte, Centex and Lennar (Charts, Fortune 500), the nation’s No. 1 builder in terms of revenue, into junk bond status earlier this month.


Three interesting points to be made here.

  1. NAR has finally taken its head out of the sand and decided that there really is a problem.

  2. Countrywide reporting a $1.2 Billion dollar loss. What is very interesting about that is they are having a national campaign to help those sub-prime and ARM borrowers refinance their loans. I would be interested to know if the Feds are backing any of that with our tax dollars?

  3. Home builders all over the country are offering HUGE discounts and incentives on their inventory homes to dump them before they are stuck with them. The builders have helped to create the mortgage and decreasing home value problems and are now helping to make it even worse.

We have many “Master Planned Communities” here that have seen a significant drop in the number of homes sold. Some are even barely started and have low occupancy rates. It will be interesting to see how the current owners are going to deal with ballooning common charges if they don’t sell the lots?

Homes sales in Orlando for September.

2007- 964
2006- 2054
2005- 2964

I guess that things are really not that bad.