Liability Limitation Clauses

Just curious

What are your liability limitations with regards to timelines relied upon in your Client Agreements and Reports?

I am an inspector in Alberta, Canada (one of only 2 provinces government regulated) and our governing licensing body prohibits the use of liability limitation clauses in our Client Agreements / Reports, and was curious how other jurisdictions inspectors are regulated.

I recently attended an insurance presentation and was shocked to find out that the Statute of Limitations starts 2 years from the “Date of Discoverability”, not 2 years from the date of inspection as previously thought, so a home inspector can potentially be sued years after they retire, and that inspector will not have insurance coverage to defend the claim frivolous or not. This is a very uneasy circumstance could leave the inspector deeply financially impacted due to legal costs to defend themselves.

In Texas a consumer has 4 years for discovery and another year to initiate an action.

Here we have no restrictions on the use of reasonable liability limitation clauses. However IMO they are useless if the Inspector does not consistently operate their business in an honest manner, does not consistently perform the service well, and does not consistently provide a well written report. Misconduct and negligence are not protected in any way and under any circumstance. Also unfortunately here, as I suspect anywhere, a person can be sued for anything and you still have to defend against it.

That is why tail coverage for insurance is important.

2 Likes

But how long should he buy tail coverage for?

When I retired, I had tail coverage for 3 years.
My attorney advised such since negligence has a 3 year statute of limitations in MI.

I think you answered your own question. Talk to your lawyer for your particular state.

1 Like

Really my point, with the bolded part of his quote, was that it didn’t appear that he would ever be out of jeopardy since his statute of limitation was from an arbitrary time in the future. ( 2 years from the “Date of Discoverability” , not 2 years from the date of inspection)

2 Likes

Best to make sure your lawyer knows what they are talking about. And to not inspect in Alberta

Thank you for your responses gents.

Generally there is a 2/10 formula in Alberta for liability limitation, however the requirements with our provincial licensing makes it interesting.

Home Inspection Business Regulations:

Prohibited wording

  1. A home inspection business shall not include a clause in a
    home inspection contract or home inspection report that
    (a) limits the liability, or the amount of liability, of the home inspection business or the home inspector for breach of contract or negligence, or

(b) limits the time for making any claim against the home inspection business or home inspector.

2/10 Formula

“The Limitations Act provides a simple formula which governs most claims. An action for what is described as a remedial order must be commenced within either (i) two years after the person making the claim knew or ought to have known of the claim, or (ii) ten years after the claim arose, whichever period first expires. Exceptions are provided where they are seen as unjust to apply the formula strictly.”

All this contract stuff is often/usually irrelevant. Most of the lunatic clients that are going to sue are going to do so regardless of any statutes or rules about when they discovered a problem. At least that’s the way it is in the US. Hopefully, your courts up north have a more streamlined way of weeding out nuts?

As far as the general idea of LOL clauses, it’s best to research your area, the allow-ability, enforceability and how specifically to write them. They are often the best defense we have as HIs but vary greatly from area to area.

And this is most likely why insurance in Canada is a great deal more than in the USA and why the number of insurance companies that cover home inspectors in Canada are so few! Horrible law that puts unrealistic expectations and conditions on the inspector.

2 Likes

Do you really think it’s most?

I probably should have said all :slight_smile:

Attorney fees is a slippery slope - I don’t have it in my agreement since I want them to know they are paying no matter what. All they have to get is $1 to “prevail”.

And I’m not saying not to put the other things in the agreement… just don’t expect miracles. It’s the old thing about anyone can sue anyone for anything anytime they want. In 20+ years and roughly 25K inspections company wide I had two actual lawsuits… both people were totally nuts and nothing in the contract (or any facts for that matter) was going to stop them. I won both - 25K in lawyer fees for one, 8K the other.

2 Likes

Thank you Matt I do have something similar in my Client Agreement, but my lawyer has said although it is a deterrent to frivolous claimants, it is not legally enforceable as client / solicitor cost awards are extremely rare and are generally defined in a percentage schedule.

In researching through the forum earlier, there was some very interesting posts 10 years ago regarding the exact topic. Some really good input back then as well.

I do not like the Alberta contract - #10 by jbushart

1 Like

There has likely been fresh case law supplementing the interpretation of the law’s language in the past ten years as well. That is also worthy of diligent research.

Thank you James. You are a valuable asset to this forum. Available case law is limited in Alberta, as so few claims against home inspectors here ever make it to a trial. I try to follow home inspection court awards on CANLII in Canada to use judgements to beef up my report language, but they are far and few between.

A rare award regarding an expensive water issue in a basement case up here recently caught my eye as the inspector reported a crack in a foundation wall and noted in his inspection report to monitor the area for water intrusion and to contact a qualified contractor for repairs as required. The judge took issue with the comment that the inspector expected the homeowner to wait until water damage actually occurred, before contacting a basement contractor. Unfortunately the inspector had to pay for a comment I bet a lot of inspectors rely on in their reports.

1 Like

In RI, we have only had licensing for like 4 years. We’re forbidden from any liability limitation clause in our agreement. State law.