Not a joke. Asked a c*de question. Yes, I saw this for real in my job as a AHJ and was searching for a particular code to hang my hat on. I have pretty broad discretion and failed that job. They removed everything down to the rafters and started over.
glad to hear they did the only sensible thing.
Common sense… good building practice. If it comes down to going to court, what structural engineer or expert witness will testify to this being an acceptable building practice? None.