TRCC (pronounced "trick") Under Attack in Texas

Originally Posted By: jbushart
This post was automatically imported from our archived forum.



Quote:

Heidi Wanken: Home buyers, beware

05:12 AM CDT on Thursday, September 8, 2005


The last thing on your mind as you're buying a new house is the possibility that anything can go wrong. There are so many other considerations ? selecting a lender, locking in an interest rate, calling moving companies, packing your worldly possessions and last, but certainly not least, time spent daydreaming about your slice of the American dream and how much you're going to love your new home.

But here in Texas, you would do yourself a favor by spending more time researching your rights and responsibilities before you sign on the dotted line. It is a perilous time to buy a new home in the Lone Star State, and buyers must be armed with information and a clear understanding of the process as they enter professionally decorated model homes where freshly baked cookies await on granite countertops, vanilla candles waft enticing fragrances and throws are placed just so on designer sofas.

There is a real world when it comes to new home ownership, and the sales pitch in the model homes is not it. I speak from experience as a new homeowner engaged in a contentious dispute with my builder over significant defects with the house.

We are currently in the middle of the State-Sponsored Inspection and Dispute Resolution process with the Texas Residential Construction Commission, the agency created during the 2003 legislative session to serve as a liaison between home builders and homeowners. But don't be fooled. The TRCC is made up of members of the building industry, and the laws were written by builders' representatives who serve on the commission. Indeed, the very senator who introduced the legislation that created the agency has expressed concern about the TRCC and stated that it needs to be revisited to ensure that homeowners' rights are protected and that the process is fair to all parties.

As we await the results of our state inspection, we stand on street corners with signs detailing the problems with our builder, have magnetic signs on our cars with information about our experience and host a Web site with more details on our situation, along with suggestions for protecting your rights and reforming the TRCC. Since we signed a mandatory arbitration clause, there is little else that we can do.

The moral of our story is this: Your home builder is not your friend, and the company isn't looking out for you. The builder will woo and court you while you're looking at the model homes and floor plans. It is an entirely different story once you own the house.

Yet there is good news. If you're willing to do your homework and stand your ground, you can emerge from the process with your rights intact and your pocketbook safe.

Here are some basic things that you can do to protect yourself, both before you buy and during the warranty period:

?Get a copy of your permit file and all the records from the construction of your home. They can be destroyed as soon as 180 days after the house is completed, so get them as soon as possible.

?Review the contract carefully and refuse to sign if it has mandatory arbitration or any gag clauses that prohibit you from speaking with the media or demonstrating against the builder.

?Before you close on the house, get a home inspection. For a few hundred dollars, an inspector will check the house thoroughly and alert you to potential problems. You will have more leverage to get any repairs done before you have closed on the house.

?Carefully examine the warranty and its terms and conditions. If they're unsatisfactory to you, look elsewhere. Don't be afraid to walk away from a bad deal ? trust your instinct and keep looking.

?The TRCC's Building and Performance Standards are the legal standard for all new homes. Go to the agency's Web site, www.trcc.state.tx.us, and read them before you commit to buying a new home regulated by these standards.

?After the purchase, document everything!

And if you have any doubt about the potential for problems, consider this: To be a builder in the state of Texas, you need only fill out a two-page form and submit a check for $125 to the TRCC.

If we had known then what we know now, we would have walked away and never looked back.

After all, there are always existing homes where the sellers are required to disclose material problems with the house, and the warranties typically offer better protection. I don't know about you, but I'll take more consumer protections over freshly baked cookies and wafting candles any day.


Heidi Wanken is a stay-at-home mom in McKinney. She is the co-founder of Texas House, a group committed to raising awareness of homeowners' rights. Her e-mail address is heidiwanken@msn.com.



--
Home Inspection Services of Missouri
www.missourihomeinspection.com

"We're NACHI. Get over it."

www.monachi.org

Originally Posted By: jhagarty
This post was automatically imported from our archived forum.



jbushart wrote:


Quote:

Heidi Wanken: Home buyers, beware

05:12 AM CDT on Thursday, September 8, 2005


Here are some basic things that you can do to protect yourself, both before you buy and during the warranty period:

?Before you close on the house, get a home inspection. For a few hundred dollars, an inspector will check the house thoroughly and alert you to potential problems. You will have more leverage to get any repairs done before you have closed on the house.


Heidi Wanken is a stay-at-home mom in McKinney. She is the co-founder of Texas House, a group committed to raising awareness of homeowners' rights. Her e-mail address is heidiwanken@msn.com.




How many New Home Buyers fail to understand this point?

Did Heidi have a Home Inspection done prior to closing?


--
Joseph Hagarty

HouseMaster / Main Line, PA
joseph.hagarty@housemaster.com
www.householdinspector.com

Phone: 610-399-9864
Fax : 610-399-9865

HouseMaster. Home inspections. Done right.

Originally Posted By: away
This post was automatically imported from our archived forum.



Joseph,


While that is a problem, most contracts I have seen just say the home is built to code. We all know what that means. In and around some areas, it isn't uncommon to see 20 or 30 subdivisions going up simultaneously, with 50 or 60 houses in each subdivision all at various stages of construction. Care to venture a guess at how many of those homes actually get a full code inspection? How many AHJ "waivers" are issued? The builder is just going to say "hey it passed code, see here is the Cert. of Occupancy".

Regardless of what the home inspector says, they have the COO. Back out of the contract? Yes you can but you may just lose any earnest money you put down. Try to sue the building official, nope they are protected. Complain to city hall, you don't have enough money to get their attention. Lots of tax money in those brand new, 200 home, subdivisions where the homes average $150 - $160. The problem is going to come back and bite them in the butt 15 years from now when structural issues make those home worthless.

Her comment about not signing a contract with binding arb or "gag" clauses is also something that probably won't happen. Except possibly with the purely custom builders and most people can't afford them anyhow. The bigger, more affordable builders just say "nope, that is our contract, take it or leave it". I guess one could always walk away and never buy a new home, but not enough will do that so, unfortunately, those clauses are here to stay.

I think the biggest problem is that most builders don't have a clue when it comes to building a house. Most just hire the cheapest subs around and hope they can make it through the first year without any major problems. Shoot just reading the TRCC standards is a hoot. I guess buying a level and actually using one to put up a wall or ceiling is beyond the capabilities of most framers in Texas nowadays. From what I have seen in my current subdivision and another I lived in, reading blueprints isn't much of a prerequisite either.

Like the article states, to be licensed, you just need $125 and a SSN. I guess if you also have a hammer, a pick up truck and a dog you would be the cream of the crop.

The TRCC sounds like a good thing (think of all the consumer protection legislation going around for HI's) but in realilty the bill was mostly written by attorneys who represent home builders and it does nothing to protect the consumer.

Rant off now, sorry for the long post.


--
Andrew Way
Keystone Residential Inspection Services PLLC
817.441.9598
www.keystoneinspections.com

Originally Posted By: rwashington
This post was automatically imported from our archived forum.



Has anyone found this ladys website? I would like to see what builder or builders she is ranting about…Search for Texas House of course brought up all the politicians icon_cool.gif



Richard W Washington


www.rwhomeinspections.com

Originally Posted By: bkelly2
This post was automatically imported from our archived forum.



http://ourtexashouse.blogspot.com/



“I used to be disgusted, Now I try to Be amused”-Elvis Costello

Originally Posted By: away
This post was automatically imported from our archived forum.



Homeowners for better buildings HOBB has a bunch of information on TRCC and some links to news stories as well.



Andrew Way


Keystone Residential Inspection Services PLLC


817.441.9598


www.keystoneinspections.com

Originally Posted By: jbushart
This post was automatically imported from our archived forum.



This is a pretty interesting phenomena in the argument for legislation.


Here is a state where the citizens are forming a variety of consumer action groups (HOBB, HADD, etc) to protect themselves from an industry that they feel there is insufficient government regulation and laws to protect them. The industry itself, however, remains relatively silent on the issue.

In other states, such as Florida, it is the industry that is forming the lobbying groups to argue for tighter and more restrictive government regulation, presumably to protect the endangered consumer, while the consumer remains silent.

![eusa_think.gif](upload://lNFeGuTetUAtwNVgUSOuUzgrGGK.gif)


--
Home Inspection Services of Missouri
www.missourihomeinspection.com

"We're NACHI. Get over it."

www.monachi.org

Originally Posted By: lleesch
This post was automatically imported from our archived forum.



James, only one thing wrong with the info in the post- it’s all wrong. The TRCC copied almost word for word the warranty provided by Residential Warranty Corporation of Texas. They were the largest insurance underwriters of the home builders in Texas concerning warranty. There are NO builders or builders resentatives on the board. I have met them all and have attended several of their seminars. I would suggest taking anything that the HOBB says with a major grain of salt. Ms Janet Ahmad, founder, has been sued and resued until she divorced her husband whom she still lives with to avoid financial ruin. She is also facing felony charges from a supposed WWII mortar shell that she planted in a KB subdivision in Dallas. These folks are not the friends of the general public as they will do whatever necessary to prove their point even if there is no point. Just as long as they remain in the spotlight. The new TRCC has just started. They had to start somewhere and I think they did the right thing. Will it get better for the consumer? I’m sure there are changes acomin’. For now, most builders in Texas are getting certified by the NAHB as a Quality Builder. It is not an easy chore and requires around 2 years to build into and a completely separate department to handle the paperwork. I think it still wise to have an independent inspector review the building at prepour, frame, and final. Most of the better builders in Texas will pay for the inspection such as Ryland, Highland, Whitestone, D R Horton, Continental, to name a few. Things are getting better for both the builder and the consumer.


Originally Posted By: jbushart
This post was automatically imported from our archived forum.



Larry,


Wow. Just, wow.

Thanks for providing the other side of the story. What do you know about the other anti-buidler association known as HADD, down your way?


--
Home Inspection Services of Missouri
www.missourihomeinspection.com

"We're NACHI. Get over it."

www.monachi.org

Originally Posted By: mboyett
This post was automatically imported from our archived forum.



lleesch wrote:
There are NO builders or builders representatives on the board.
Larry, I'm confused. How can you say there are no builders on the TRCC? This is from their website home page:

The Commission:
The Commission is comprised of nine members appointed by the Governor: four registered builders, three members of the general public, one engineer who practices in the area of residential construction and one either architect or inspector who practices in the area of residential construction. The Commission members serve six-year staggered terms.

Art Cuevas (Cuevas Construction), John Krugh (Perry Homes Corp Counsel), Glenda Marriott (VP, Marriott Homes) and Scott Porter (Porter Contracting, Custom Homes) are all builders or builders' reps.

Don't get me wrong, I fully support the TRCC and agree with the rest of your post. I'm just confused on this one little part.


--
Mike Boyett
Capital City Inspections
Austin, Tx
www.capcityinspections.com

Originally Posted By: mboehmer
This post was automatically imported from our archived forum.



mboyett wrote:
lleesch wrote:
There are NO builders or builders representatives on the board.
Larry, I'm confused. How can you say there are no builders on the TRCC? This is from their website home page:

The Commission:
The Commission is comprised of nine members appointed by the Governor: four registered builders, three members of the general public, one engineer who practices in the area of residential construction and one either architect or inspector who practices in the area of residential construction. The Commission members serve six-year staggered terms.

Art Cuevas (Cuevas Construction), John Krugh (Perry Homes Corp Counsel), Glenda Marriott (VP, Marriott Homes) and Scott Porter (Porter Contracting, Custom Homes) are all builders or builders' reps.

Don't get me wrong, I fully support the TRCC and agree with the rest of your post. I'm just confused on this one little part.


Absolutely correct about the TRCC composition - however the main point that is not being spoken about is that a homeowner must go through this state mandated arbitration process before they can go to court and sue the builder. The other BIG problem is that even if TRCC finds the builder is at fault for the home's defects - they have no enforcement powers! NONE - can't get money and have no way to force the builder to correct the problems. There was much lobbying at the state legislature last year - to no avail - to give TRCC some teeth to back up their actions.


Originally Posted By: jbushart
This post was automatically imported from our archived forum.



Quote:
ABC 20/20 will air a show titled "Defective Home Construction" Friday Oct 7,
2005 10:00 PM EST. http://abcnews.go.com/2020/



--
Home Inspection Services of Missouri
www.missourihomeinspection.com

"We're NACHI. Get over it."

www.monachi.org

Originally Posted By: rdawes
This post was automatically imported from our archived forum.



There is an anecdote floating around that when the TRCC staff was writing the regulations, that someone added “and no homeowner shall be allowed to own a 4 ft. level” into them as a joke. Of course it was supposed to be removed before publishing but was not. The state legislators were not amused.


Like all cute anecdotes, this should be taken with a grain of salt.


Originally Posted By: jbushart
This post was automatically imported from our archived forum.



I missed the broadcast. Anything to it?



Home Inspection Services of Missouri


www.missourihomeinspection.com


"We're NACHI. Get over it."

www.monachi.org

Originally Posted By: rwashington
This post was automatically imported from our archived forum.



Broadcast was alot of fluff. A couple got ripped off from their GC but they never did mention inspections. The house was a complete nightmare. That story would have been an excellent time to mention our profession. Another story was how much 200k would buy in a 15m home? icon_rolleyes.gif


All in all you did not miss a thing.



Richard W Washington


www.rwhomeinspections.com