What you’re missing is that the 50 amp circuit breaker is not providing overload protection, motor overloads are integral to the fan motor and compressor. So if a condition exists where there is overheating the integral protection in the motor will protect the conductors. The 50 amp circuit breaker is only there for ground fault and short circuit protection which is why is can be larger than the ampacity of the conductors.
That brings up a question I have Robert. Since the OCPD is only there for ground fault/short circuit, what goes into the manufacturer’s specification of its max size? In a true short circuit or ground fault, wouldn’t a OCPD of just about any size trip (assuming everything has been wired correctly)?
Good questions. The manufacturer comes up with the MCA (minimum circuit ampacity) which is used to size the conductors. That is roughly figured by taking the largest motor running amps (compressor)*125% + the fan motor running amps. The MaxOCPD is sized to allow the unit to start. How that is calculated I’m unsure.
Regarding the short circuit and ground fault protection you’re correct that during a fault the only limiting factor is the resistance of the wire therefore the current flow can be thousands of amps which will very quickly trip an OCPD even when that is much larger than the conductor ampacity.
It would seem like the minimum circuit ampacity would cover the start up. In other words, anything less than the minimum will create possible nuisance trips during start-up.
I agree which is why the branch circuit is code complaint even if the OCPD is smaller than the MaxOCPD on the nameplate but at least as large as the MCA (minimum circuit ampacity).
Just want to say I’m truly impressed by all the knowledge bombs being dropped here. You HIs know your stuff ![]()
That’s exactly what I am saying. That panel on new construction was inspected. Did the inspector miss it or approve it? I see city inspectors approve code violations constantly. City inspectors are like preachers with the Bible, they can and do interpret, ignore, or change anything they want to in any way they want to, in the code books.
I encounter the same. There are often times where I find something that you, Robert, would find to be a code violation. The builder tells the buyer that since the AHJ passed the building & has issued a CO they do not have to fix it. The sad part is that they in fact do not have to fix it in those situations as the building has passed.
I always recommend to my client to contact the AHJ & ask them to come review the issue as they are the only ones that can amnend their inspection & require the builder to fix it.
@rmeier2
You guys act surprised that things get missed by the AHJ. When I was doing HVAC there were times that we had just started tearing out the old furnace and had to cut a hole in the box so the inspector could slap his sticker on the new furnace. Things get overlooked all the time.
Not even close. I am saying that there is a likelihood that the inspector approved it just like in your example.
Would you have a problem with a technician that is doing work at your house using your restroom?
Just take a piss if you need to, man. It’s not a big deal. No need to feel shame, we’re all humans.
“Taking a piss” is not the same as “Using the facilities”, and you know it!!
I’d argue you’re using the same facilities (the restroom) in either case.
If you taking a piss is gonna stink up and clog/overflow the ‘facilities’, you damn well better be seeing a doctor, and soon!!
Don’t need to… it’s a non-issue.
I’ve NEVER had a Professional ask for permission to use my Restroom. They know better!
You Hobbyists do as you will, while I keep raking in the dough, as Professionals get the referrals and big dollar jobs!
That doesn’t address my point at all.
Wow, do I regret mentioning “facilities.” (It’s all Tom’s fault).
Youse Hobbyists really need to learn to pay attention if you ever expect to elevate your standing in life!!
you cut off the part about how you wait until after the inspection
I think it’s safe to say that inspectors will argue about anything & everything.
No they won’t. ![]()