Undersized conductors for condenser?

I’m mostly messing around…

1 Like

In 15 years, I have only gone once. The home was vacant, and the buyer & buyer’s agent said that they would not be able to attend. I debated going but my stomach was not doing well. It was in a master bathroom with high vaulted ceilings. The walls in the bathroom did not go all the way up. About two minutes after I went, I see the agent’s car pull in the driveway. With him are the two buyers. The cheap 50 CFM bath fan could not do anything to mask just how bad it was. When everyone came in, I asked the agent how long the house had been vacant. He asked why and I said that the traps in the sink & shower were dry, so sewer gas had entered the home. A dozen or so years later I still don’t know if they bought my excuse.

9 Likes

Especially when the antangonist can’t even be bothered to become a Professional Internachi Member!!
Professionals ‘Commit’.
Hobbyists ‘Troll’.

Yeah, that’s right… I said it!!

2023-11-17_135500

1 Like

Quick thinking! I’ve got a couple embarrassing stories similar to that. I, too would prefer to avoid that.

I think Ohio has rules about this.

You can use the toilet but you have to leave the seat down!

1 Like

6 Likes

Ewww! That is exactly what it looked like in a Guatemalan movie theater toilet when I was down there back in 1978-79.

Some unfortunate people had Montezuma’s revenge before I walked in. Yuk!

3 Likes

Since it is NM cable, it is sized by the 60°C column, which limits it to 30A, so 8 AWG NM cable is required, but if THWN conductors were used 10 AWG has a ampere rating of 35A in this application, it would not if a normal branch circuit.

1 Like

I’m curious, dont you ever come across oversized breakers for hvac units? It is very common, which is why you have to go by the max OCPD and the minimum ampacity requirements on the unit label.
As far as I know, this is the only time you can have oversized breakers. (with hvac equipment)

So, would you call out a breaker that is larger than the unit requirements, if it only acts as a ground fault protection?
I see it quite often… Just today, I had a 60 amp breaker for a condenser, and the unit called for a 40 amp max. (wasnt swapped out when the a/c was replaced)

Yes, the MaxOCPD size on the nameplate is required to be followed. If a new unit is installed as a replacement the OCPD must follow the nameplate.

Thanks. Your comment seemed to suggest that it didnt matter, if it was just for fault protection…
I figured that wasnt what you meant, though

Yes I see them quite often and call them out when they are Larger Than What The Manufacturer Allows/Specifies as The “Max Fuse” and “Max CKT-BKR”…Like today the “Min Circuit Amps 25.2” and Max CKT-BKR 40A…The Panel has a 50 Amp breaker installed for the unit. The Manufacturers Put that there for a reason. In the case of the OP, those #10 AWG and 50amp breaker is compounding the problem and is a fire waiting to happen.
Our local Code inspectors started calling this out, or rather enforcing it about 6-7 years ago because there were fires attributed to this exact “wrong installation” and improper over current protection. Electricians on new construction had no idea what the equipment would call for and would wire the circuit to handle 50amps and would throw in the 50A breakers later the HVAC was installed and many time Max would be much less than 50A.

1 Like

Correct… Your comment made it sound like you never see hvac breakers larger than the conductors it is feeding… :slightly_smiling_face:

I don’t see it as a wink and a nod, “Not really a defect” situation. I use the analogy of driving a car. If the speed limit is 30MPH and a driver is driving 32.5MPH, the risk of a crash goes up marginally. Recognizing that fact is not the same as condoning driving over the speed limit. It is a question of risk tolerance. A good cop will take other factors into account such as weather conditions, traffic density, and so on.

Published, and enforced, conductor ampacities are essentially rules of thumb. There are many variables that influence a conductor’s ampacity at any given point in time. It constantly changes based on the environment, inductive coupling, and a variety of other factors, just as the risk of a crash is not solely dependent on the stated speed limit

The reality is that there is a tremendous amount of safety margin built into published capacities of electrical equipment and materials, especially here in North America. Compare our North American ratings to the ratings of similar equipment and materials in any European or Asian country and you’ll see what I mean.

So, yes, by the ratings assigned by the manufacturer of the equipment and the agreed upon standards (by way of the NEC, in particular), of the conductors, breakers, and so on, it is technically not in compliance. That doesn’t necessarily equate to being a defect.

This is an example of why installation approvals are made by code compliance inspectors or engineers. The NEC specifically says that the inspector or an engineer makes the final call. Published ratings are based on statistical averages with plenty of built-in headroom. There are times when common sense should prevail.

Thinking of all the compliance inspectors I’ve worked with over the years, and my own experience as as former code compliance inspector, I have no doubt that some would issue a citation for driving one mile an hour over the limit, but most will take into account the big picture in making a judgment call. That often involves taking into account the practical aspects of an installation, such as the closest standard breaker size, conductor sizes, and the installation environment.

5 Likes
2 Likes

I guess my narrative may need some work!

I now understand the breaker does not provide overload protection because the motors have it built in but provides ground fault and short circuit protection.

@rmeier2 So what is the defect/narrative for a breaker larger than the mfr requirement if the motors provide overload protection and any size breaker provides ground fault and short circuit protection? Edit: Is the narrative only that it doesn’t match the mfr’s requirements or is there a real safety hazard? I’ve gotten turned around on this one.

@ruecker Did your narrative change after this discussion?

IMO the narrative is simply that the nameplate MaxOCPD size is required to be followed. Even if a larger OCPD will work without any issues it’s not for an inspector or the installer to decide that.

1 Like

As far as my narrative for oversized OCPD? No, my narrative didn’t change. But my narrative doesn’t suggest it is a safety hazard. It basically says “this is what the manuf calls for as the max, and what is installed is larger than that.”

1 Like