Bonding Screw in Subpanel

I see that some inspectors will carry a small bag of dead front screws in case a homeowners panel is using screws that could damage the panel, insulation on wiring, etc. With this in mind could I remove a bonding screw if it was in a Subpanel?

1 Like

you could, but i wouldn’t touch it. that would be working on a home i inspect. illegal in wv for 12 months after the inspection. it may not be but wouldn’t be worth it to me to find out. besides, i got into inspecting to avoid doing work. then what happens if the electricity goes out as soon as that screw gets pulled? or the arc that flashed reaches out and grabs you? way too many things could happen for me to assume the extra risk and liability.

3 Likes

Actually that only applies for paid work, you can in fact tighten up a door know or replace a missing outlet cover or remove a bonding screw if you wanted. The code of ethics only applies to paid work. Just do whatever you want so you don’t have to report on these little things.

1 Like

There is a significant percentage of home inspectors I prefer not to “repair” my home. :wink:

Regardless, my recommendation is to observe and report.

6 Likes

Arguably, tightening a doorknob is low risk. Replacing an outlet cover doesn’t have much risk. Removing a bonding screw has a higher risk and you darn sure better be positive about what you are doing. I used to throw unwired breakers to the “Off” position. But then an attorney pointed out to me that every time I fix anything, I could end up owning it. I may not mind owning the occasional doorknob, but I don’t want to own anything electrical.

7 Likes

You could, but I would not recommend it.

Adding a proper panel front screw to replace a screw that is considered dangerous and a hazard is different from modifying the internal panel by removing a boding screw.

If you were an inspector at my company, you would be suspended and most likely terminated.

4 Likes

Before removing the bond screw you would need to be absolutely 100% sure that you know what you’re doing. A sub-panel with a 3-wire feeder and the bond screw removed could be suddenly become ungrounded creating an additional hazard. If the cover were removed and you saw the bond screw was improperly installed and you removed it before you ever snapped a photo it’s likely no one would ever know that you removed it. IMO let the sparky investigate the problem and find a solution.

6 Likes

Really appreciate everyone weighing in. This was helpful.

1 Like

Leave it alone.
If you see an immediate detrimental safety item, advise the home owners verbally.

3 Likes

You can do whatever you want and you can take responsibility for the consequences of your actions.

As a forensic electrical investigator, I had a standard list of questions I would ask. Many of those questions were asked specifically because the lawyers wanted to have the questions asked. Among those were questions about who did ANY electrical work, or who had access to the electrical system.

Some lawyers are hotshots who are bloodthirsty. They will take a shotgun approach and bring everyone they can into the legal quagmire. Some are more reasonable and focus on the most likely culpable person.

Only you can decide how much unnecessary risk (and yes, it is unnecessary) you want to expose yourself to.

I have heard many inspectors say that they do stuff like that all the time.They will brag about how everyone loves them.

I am more like the paramedic who tells everyone to wear a seatbelt because they have pulled too many dead bodies from cars.

I have often disagreed with the hotshot lawyers who want to win at any cost. That has included times when I told them that they were barking up the wrong tree by going after home inspectors. They may or may not take my advice.

Then there is the question of your professional liability insurance. What does your insurance cover? My insurance covered inspections and doing electrical work My insurance provider only covered me for electrical work because I am a licensed electrical contractor. I could not do ANY other repairs, regardless of how minor.

My advice is to leave your Mighty Mouse cape in the closet.

5 Likes

I am new with the Forum but have been inspecting houses since February 1st. I Inspected a house that was built in 1910. the issue is the house has a disconnect outside the house next to meter can. The subpanel is in basement. Since the disconnect is outside the panel in inside is a subpanel. The subpanel has a green screw inside the panel. That screw seems to me that it has never been set into the back of the subpanel. Has any of you ran across this before. Please see pictures.

I do understand that the green grounding screw should not be set into panel. Can the green grounding screw be removed ? Or is that not necessary.

The screw is factory installed in the bus but is not screwed down into the enclosure. For a sub-panel it would remain that way. I usually throw them away to avoid confusion down the road. That panels has several visible issues.

3 Likes

The neutrals and grounds are bonded in the panel, they should not be, if the bonding strap wasn’t there, the green screw needs to be tightened down to bond the ground bar to the panel

How many wires are in the feeder to the panel?

1 Like

Cut grounding conductors in upper right.

The bonding strap between the neutral and grounding bars must be removed in this subpanel and the green screw is tightened down to bond the grounding bar to the panel in this subpanel.

Unless I am having a brain fart this morning, your comment does not describe this photo. In this configuration, the tightened down green screw would bond the panel to the grounding conductors after the neutral and grounding bars are separated from each other.

1 Like

He stated the the bonding screw was not screwed in therefore it was not bonding the bus to the enclosure.

Hi All

First thanks for all the feedback.

I would not remove the grounding screw myself. I would put it on the report for qualified electrician to remove the grounding screw. So first questions to confirm is that panel a sub panel? Second question is the screw not set in panel (as far as you can see) and should remain unset? To me it is a sub panel due to disconnect is outside. Yes I am aware there is a grounding wire on the neutral buss. Which should be moved to the grounding buss.

Thanks again

Todd

Yes if the OCPD at the meter is the service disconnect that is a sub-panel.

At the sub-panel there should be a separate bus for the neutrals and and a separate bus for the EGC’s.

That green screw should not be threaded into the metal enclosure at the sub-panel when there are neutral conductors landed on the bus.

The bus with the green screw is for the neutral conductors only. That includes the bus on the left that it is connected to. This panel requires a SEPARATE ground bus be attached directly to the enclosure for the grounds. They should not be located on the supplied neutral busses (left or right) in a sub-panel.

That strap that connects the 2 neutral busses also connects the bus bar for those breakers that need a neutral connection (AFCI/GFCI). It should not be removed!

1 Like

Hi Robert

Thanks for taking time to answer.

So are you saying that the sub panel is wired wrong and there should be a seperated ground buss bar attached to back of panel box for the ground wires only. The two buss bars now are for neutral wires only. That would be a big problem then. So someone will need to screw in place a ground buss bar which will be fastened to back of panel and all grounded wires will have to move to that new buss bar. is that correct?

Thanks Todd