Cold Joint - How About is this joint?

Hi everyone,

I’m looking for some professional opinions on this foundation joint on a new residential build. It looks like a clear cold joint from a delayed concrete pour.

It is located in the wall right where the porch will be. The builder has applied a waterproofing membrane and claims that it is structurally sound and nothing to worry about.

  • Structural Concerns: Given the builder’s claims, does a joint like this typically impact structural integrity in a porch area, or is he right that it’s nothing to worry about?

  • Waterproofing: Is a standard waterproofing membrane sufficient for a cold joint here, or should it be injected/sealed further?

Any insights, experiences, or advice on how to address this would be greatly appreciated!

Ask the foundation guy where his rebar is located; horizontal - and vertical if used. That joint looks structurally sound to me. What is the soil type, clay? I’d recommend a peel and stick waterproofing, vs paint on. Mel-Rol is used around here. If clay soil, the backfill should be clean gravel.

6 Likes

Agree.
A ‘paint on’ or ‘spray on’ proofing system is typically considered “Damp proofing”, not “Waterproofing”.

1 Like

when i was a union carpenter working on the new stacks at a powerplant, they had a continuous pour on the stacks to avoid cold joints using slip forms that got smaller as they went. then they stopped for a week and had a huge cold joint about 250ft from the top. when i asked about it i was told they had enough rebar inside to stand without the concrete. having worked on the foundations welding supports for anchor bolts in the august sun inside the 15ft forms i had to agree.

that is what i know about cold joints, enough rebar and they are irrelevant. as for the waterproofing, i’ve read good things about the newer crystalline waterproofing that sprays on. haven’t used it since i stopped working with concrete and building houses over a decade ago though. it supposedly goes on and if you keep it moist for a week it penetrates to an inch in and forms a waterproof seal when it reacts with the concrete. i seriously doubt it will leak any more than any other part of the wall but am unsure about that.

1 Like

My first thought just looking at is, WTF is this the first time the concrete guy poured a fountain? Would you pay full price for a new car when it was delivered it had dents and scratches? Second thought is the contractor knows why this happened, the contractor may have delayed the pour by not being properly prepared, the concrete truck got delayed because ___ you fill in the blank, there was a lack of manpower, piss poor planning… the list goes on. Long term stability of the foundation depends more on the design of the reinforcement steel, back fill material and exterior waterproofing method. The very least the contractor can do is grout the wall and make it appear he cares about the quality of work.

6 Likes

Last January on a phase inspection, the honey combing was so deep that it would hold my pen anywhere I put it. When I came back, the grout repair looked like a finger painting. I told the client to make a big deal about it with the builder and watch them put his complaint in writing, because I wouldn’t be surprised that five or so years from now, that grouting will be flaking out.

In the OP’s photo, the right side appears grouted. Did they run out, or that was really bad?

1 Like

Thank you, Michael!

There is vertical rebar present. Here is a picture of it where I’ve highlighted in red the section of the wall that has the cold joint:

that’s just the rebar that ties it to the footer, not the stuff that has to be there to hold the wall together. there probably is but you can’t verify it unless you saw it before the pour or you could infer that because you saw a huge pile of rebar on the ground prior to the pour that wasn’t there afterwards that it was put inside the forms but that would be an assumption and we all know what those things do…

1 Like

Hi Lon

Not grouted yet! The photo makes it look worse than it really is.

Thanks Timothy. I have this photo from before the pour—does this show the rebar you’re talking about?

looks like it has rebar, just not nearly enough of it, but you’d have to compare the drawings for that. they include a detail on the prints to show the type and spacing of rebar required for the wall. in my experience it looks as if it it is woefully inadequate but hard to say if they followed the instructions or not without seeing them. one thing about it i can say for sure is if they left the rebar up against the forms like that it doesn’t matter if they put more in or not since they don’t have enough coverage on it. it needs to have at least 2" of concrete over the rebar.

The forms do not look complete in that photo. I don’t see the rebar. Unless they do things very differently there…

1 Like

Thanks Timothy. I do see rebar now you mentioned it. I double-checked local codes, and Michigan requires a minimum of two horizontal rebar runs, which appears to be met based on the pre-pour photo.

I also read, too many rebars are also bad for foundation. what’s your thought on that?

As for the vertical rebar: I believe they extended vertical rebars up from the footing dowels, though looking closely at the setup, the spacing seems pretty inconsistent—ranging anywhere from 16 to 24 inches (and possibly wider in a few spots).

Good point on the concrete coverage/clearance near the forms, too. I believe concrete was poured past then based my other pictures.

Regarding the soil: the lot is primarily sandy soil. According to the USDA/NRCS hydric soils data, my specific lot scores very low for hydric soils—though there can still be a minor seasonal rise in the water table, so proper drainage and sealing will still be key.

To be honest, I’m not entirely sure if additional rebar was added after that photo was taken. Unfortunately, I don’t have any photos taken between that stage and when the basement walls were fully poured and filled.

Where in Michigan are you?

SE Michigan, New Haven.