Today at a new construction site that has had the city sign off on the CO, the deck guardrail posts were not compliant with the new standards. It may be that the city is not current. They did not answer a call to them. Here is a photo of the guard.
Sheesh Bob, what’s with the animosity? The article that you posted is absolutely based on code, but it is old code and no longer applicable to today’s standards which are described in today’s IRC. This house was a new build and unless the city is under an older code (around here some of our cities are slow to adopt most recent code), then that deck is not compliant. BTW, I will try again on Monday to reach someone at the city. I am curious.
Yeah, most of us say this all the time and there are some good reasons why. But that comment is not an excuse for ignorance.
“Standards” or “code” is a bit of semantics. I advise against using the word “code” as much as possible and never in a report. But I don’t suffer any illusion that our inspections and reporting are guided by something other than by code. When we get challenged about whether some defect that we report is actually a defect, it often comes down to, is “it” code compliant or not?
We are not code inspectors because:
a) we often work in many different jurisdictions with many different codes being enforced
b) we are inspecting homes built over a wide time period under many different codes
c) codes are changing every three years and keeping up with every code change and the adoptions by every jurisdiction that we are working in is very difficult
However, that does not absolve us from being ignorant. “We are not code inspectors” is a flimsy excuse for not paying attention to the major code changes.
No animosity. Your post was vague. Thanks for the update - don’t be so sensitive.
Curiously the numbers given in the article I posted are the same in 2021. The addition of a Deck section in 2021 IRC deals primarily with loads for different species of lumber, Guardrail loads remain the same.
I only write those guardrails up if it’s a safety hazard because they appear loose or weak-if bolts are too small the I say “Client should consider upgrading lag bolts to 5/8” or 1/2" for safety reasons " Usually It’s Ledger board bolts that to small- Also the Key wording for me is " At the time of inspection "was it loose ? Keep it simple!
I would call out those small bolts and write hard. No “client consideration” needed. I recommend correction. Because my observations in the field tell me those small bolts/lags or whatever are junk due to the small head and washer.
For me, the big question is “is it loose or not?” first… If it is, then no reference is needed. If it is not loose, then referring the code, with the explanation, “This is the code requirement, because…” and how upgrading will KEEP it from getting loose. This way, I’m relating it to safety and best practice.
I agree that “loose” is a problem, but even if not, the lags are still undersized. I don’t do code references in a report. I just report undersized. If I am questioned or challenged, then I’ll email or verbally offer the associated code. I am in the camp, of “never use the code word or quote code in a report.”
Bob, that’s the main reason I (almost) never cite a code reference. I work in so many different areas, and each one has adopted various parts of code at various times, so what applies in THIS city, may not over there. And some cities don’t even inspect some projects, like fences and balconies - they just approve a drawing.
While I am disappointed in what I am seeing in these pictures. There is not a code requirement that the bolts be ½ in (they should have washers)
1/2-inch diameter through-bolts (typically two per post, with washers) are the standard prescriptive recommendation in guides like the AWC DCA 6 Prescriptive Residential Wood Deck Construction Guide and most manufacturer details for 4x4 or 4x6 posts
The actual adopted code shows in some pictographs ½ in hardware, and we also show that in our guides. Mainly because of AWC. The actual code reads that its performance-based and must withstand outward concentrated loads. (200lbs)
I can find the requirement for ½" in areas like the ledger board, however, we would accept alternatives like ledger locks