First post, new member!

hi everyone!

This is my first post and I’m a new member so bear with me :slight_smile:

I attached a photo of a roof I’m inspecting as part of my course, side note the roofing inspection course is amazing and it’s kicking my butt, but I digress, and I noticed that there’s a nail that’s sitting in the shingle and I’m wondering if that’s considered a defect.

Thanks folks!! Happy inspecting!

1 Like

The shiner is a defect and possibly another one directly below it. Something that I would note in my report.

From what I can see in your photo, I would note that the roof has surpassed its normal life expectancy and recommend replacement.

1 Like

Thanks so much Jeff, I’m curious as to why you’re saying the rest has past its life span. What else do you see in the picture that makes you say that?

The nail is a defect. I don’t see it like Jeff does. It’s showing age related deterioration, but still performing (keeping the house dry while probably still insurable). Ask what the roof age is. If it is 10-12 years old, then it’s looking age appropriate. If it is 5-8 years old, it may have insufficient attic ventilation and is prematurely aging due to overheating. That is very common.
Regarding insurability, know what your area does. Until a couple of years ago, around my parts, that roof would be insurable, but recent changes here, now make a roof showing this look questionable. When in doubt (and maybe just CYA until you get more experience) tell your client that the roof is showing some age-related deterioration, and they should confirm that their insurance will cover it.

3 Likes

Other than the nail pops and appearance I see other issues, like the caulked shingles on the side of the skylight. Those were not installed correctly and wouldn’t be surprised if there is or was a leak around the skylight.

What is the grate on the left?? It looks like it’s fastened to the roof but can’t quite tell. The picture gets fuzzy when zooming in all the way.

2 Likes

Homeowner says the roof was put up in 2016. That great to the left was something a roofer installed because of animals getting into the Attic. The skylight was originally installed improperly and a roofer came out and fixed the flashing and ice and shield and then re-lay shingles. There is no sign of moisture anywhere around the Skylight confirmed by a moisture reader.

Can I just say I really appreciate this conversation.

1 Like

Welcome to the InterNACHI message board Annamaria!

1 Like

Welcome to InterNACHI MB Annamaria!

Yes, the protruding nails are defects as they can create a potential leak path.

2 Likes

Good eye, Lon. :+1:

6 Likes

@apino2

3 Likes

Looks like a wet roof. I’m thinking those two “nail heads” may be beads of water?

1 Like

If you enlarge the photos, it looks like some pretty significant granule loss and crazing.

1 Like

Im really not trying to be mean, but you guys are clowns

way to easy to get a home inspector license

Many here are and don’t realize it. :wink:

Ditto Loyd

giphy

It can be really hard to tell in a photo with this type/color shingle. I’m not sure I really see significant granule loss, personally. From just this one photo, I would hesitate to say “end of life.” They look fairly good to my eyes.

3 Likes