Jeff, you’ve been inspecting for this long and you’ve never had a tradesman throw you under the bus? Pretty lucky. I’m happy for you. It’s only happened a few times for me, but it’s annoying as hell. I had an HVAC system that was over 20 years old, and I actually had a video with sound that showed the system running LOUDLY. My report said it needed eval and possible replacement. The A/C guy came out, declared the system dead and offered to sell a new one. Told the new home owner “There’s no way this was working when they inspected it.” and the client tried to come after me to replace the system! I lost several referrals because the realtor involved stopped referring me after that.
Kevin, don’t you think it’s a responsible thing to let a new 1st-time home buyer know that? Maybe there is no remedy, but it shouldn’t be a surprise.
Absolutely. I’ve never had a client tell me I gave them too much information. ![]()
Bob, any idea WHY GFCI’s are not required to be on a dedicated circuit? Seems like that would be a good thing. I realize the cost of material could be higher, but it could keep it simple…???
I haven’t.
You’re correct dedicated circuits are not required for the receptacles you’ve described. Dual function circuit breakers are permitted to provide the GFCI protection when required by the NEC.
As far having bathroom lights on a GFCI breaker it is not required nor is it prohibited so there is nothing to report.
IMO, those two statement should be exclusive of one another.
- As far having bathroom lights on a GFCI breaker it is not required nor is it prohibited (good to know)
- there is nothing to report. (subjective. This is for the inspector to decide regardless of code or regulation)
As you can see, @rkenney and I have a different opinion. But, that does not make Bob wrong or me right. In his experience or training, he has concerns. Which he was hired to express in the best interest of his client. My disagreement does not lay with interpretation of code, it is elsewhere.
IMO, I think Bob is speaking more as an electrician or electrical inspector than as a general home inspector. Strictly speaking as per code, there is nothing to report… but as a generalist inspector, I’m not concerned with the code interpretation. IMO, having lights go out in a dark room can be unsafe or at least “unsettling” whether allowed by code or not.
The code does not tell one to install the bathroom lights on the GFCI circuit… it just doesn’t prohibit it.I don’t usually see this in a new construction (though now, I assume I will more)… I usually see this in an older flipped house where someone installed a GFCI where there wasn’t one before.
Sure you’re being paid for your opinion but in the case of lighting with GFCI protection it’s code compliant. The purpose of the code is safety and it doesn’t care if it’s inconvenient for someone to have to reset a GFCI device. Would one consider this being reported as an FYI for the buyer or a defect that requires remediation? I’m curious what would be the expected outcome after reporting the lighting with GFCI protection?
NEC 90.1 Purpose.
(B) Adequacy. This Code contains provisions that are considered necessary for safety. Compliance therewith and proper maintenance result in an installation that is essentially free
from hazard but not necessarily efficient, convenient, or adequate for good service or future expansion of electrical use.
Great questions.
- Would one consider this being reported as an FYI for the buyer or a defect that requires remediation? (no, I would not consider reporting this as FYI or a defect that requires remediation. Bob and Andrew have concerns that lights out may leave someone in a dangerous situation. We can disagree)
- I’m curious what would be the expected outcome after reporting the lighting with GFCI protection? (I don’t have expected outcomes or views into a crystal ball. I make a recommendation and leave it up to those involved to decide. I do not fear being challenged by outside trades as to why or how I came to my conclusions. And I trust I am operating in the best interest of my client.)
Let me ask this… is there a benefit to HAVING the lights on the GFCI circuit? I don’t see one. IMO, this is a case of “it’s not prohibited” so I can do what I want and I save a few $$ in copper by running less wire. I guess we will disagree that having lights go out suddenly in a dark windowless room is an issue… especially when light fixtures are mandated by code in other places… like the attic, or by the entry.
Does that include exterior outlets? That seems to be what he was most concerned about. Exterior GFCI tripping while someone was taking a bath.
@rmeier2 thinks it is all about code. He has no clue what a home inspection is or should be nor has he ever done one. Code, once again, is not why an item makes or doesn’t make the report. Yes, lighting on a GFCI is a defect. So is having to run down two flights of stairs in the morning to reset the master bath GFCI protected outlet. So is a refrigerator on a GFCI protected outlet. Each of these items in my opinion is sloppy thoughtless work. No thought was given to the practical use and living condition of the installation.
Lighting WITHOUT GFCI protection is also code compliant. Had a little thought been given to the installation it could easily be done differently. Code thumpers don’t think. Code says they don’t have to:
NEC 90.1 Purpose.
. . . not necessarily efficient, convenient, or adequate for good service or future expansion of electrical use.
Don’t worry in three years we will change it !
The odds are better that a bulb burns out and leaves them in the dark, then a GFCI trips and leaves them in the dark.
The odds are also better that you could have a power failure during your shower than the GFCI tripping.
Outside of inspecting, I don’t think I’ve ever had a GFCI trip on me. I have had the power go out many times, and have had burned out light bulbs lots of times.
They also are rarely good electricians. They focus too much on memorizing stuff and not enough on thinking and understanding. They don’t take the time to learn how electricity and electrical systems work. Consequently, they make bad decisions when tasked with designing or laying out electrical systems. They are also notoriously inept at troubleshooting.
I can train a certified electronics technician with minimal experience to be a good electrical system troubleshooter in a small fraction of the time it takes to train a code thumper with 10 or 15 years experience. The reason is that electronics techs have to understand electricity and be able to think, whereas electricians don’t.
The exterior receptacles require GFCI protection and can be fed from a GFCI protected branch circuit that also supplies lighting on the interior of the home. Might not be the best design but it is permitted as this is a design issue not a code issue. As Dave stated builders don’t see problem when the installation is code compliant even if the design is poor. And as others have mentioned while there is a theoretical potential for tripping in the scenario you’ve mentioned this is not a real world problem.
Unless you are 92!
What is a “real world problem?” Perhaps that is a new narrative for Home Inspectors. “Well, sir, it is not a real world problem!”
My point from earlier is that power loss is power loss, regardless of the cause, whether it’s a storm, a GFCI trip, a breaker trip, or another issue. If you attribute GFCI to causing this issue, then why not account for different power loss scenarios? No one can disagree that getting caught naked, soapy, and wet in a bathroom during a power outage might be a hazard for the elderly, but why stop with GFCI? Emergency back-up lighting is a thing…recommend it!