HVAC duct sealing at floor penetration

Hi guys, first post here and just trying to learn more and more everyday. Is my evaluation of the situation correct given the picture attached?

The picture shows an HVAC duct passing through a conditioned bi-level (semi-basement) floor to the main floor’s living room. We can see light passing through the opening on the top right corner of the duct passage. Now for conditioned-to-conditioned spacing, it isn’t of much concern from energy efficiency standpoint since the HVAC system will try to keep both spaces in around the same temperature but the moisture vapors passing through the opening in case of any temperature or humidity differential, especially in case (a) window(s) is open in one of the two floors will drive the vapors through these openings and all the assembly therein. This puts the integrity of the system at risk in the long term. Looking forward to a compact feedback.

You have an image from the finished floor? Typically sealed from the top. Remove the floor register to see if you can see the boot sealed.

1 Like

It’s not a problem.

If you have uninsulated duct in an unconditioned space, then you need to be concerned about condensation. That would be the larger issue.

1 Like

The register boot needs to be sealed to prevent air leakage. Mastic is the common and best choice for sealing the boot to prevent air leaks at the subfloor. Another issue will be the uninsulated boot, which will cause condensation to form. If this is not addressed, the subfloor will become wet/damp, and mold will eventually grow.

3 Likes

I see no problems with this installation!

5 Likes

Having said that…
Lack of air-sealing at penetrations in the building thermal envelope can cause serious issues in my area. Energy efficiency standards spell it out, for instance:

https://codes.iccsafe.org/content/FLEC2023P1/chapter-4-re-residential-energy-efficiency#FLEC2023P1_RE_Ch04_SecR402.4.1.1_TblR402.4.1.1

4 Likes

Agree, but in this case, it’s not penetrating the thermal envelope.

3 Likes

What is a semi-basement?

Unless that air duct conditions both upper and lower floors it must be sealed to separate the two zones.

1 Like

Had the OP NOT seen the light in the corner, would this have even been observed as a potential defect? How many inspectors even take the time to actively look for this (potential) defect?
My guess, is ZERO!
So… Move along… Nothing to see here!!

2 Likes

I agree, don’t see this as a problem or defect, and it is all dependent on the area or the conditional installation of the area. In my area, I would have walked right by.

1 Like

It’s a level where the grade is below the finished floor on one side but higher on the opposite side, common in Canadian topography.

Agreed, I thought so it should be properly sealed to provide an air barrier and keep air out of the flooring, regardless if both levels are conditioned or not. Not a ‘defect’, but not a best practice either. Just my evaluation.

That’s what’s keeping me on the edge with this. It’s definitely not a thermal envelope issue. Having said that, we know occupants like to experience reasonable moisture to feel comfortable but moisture still doesn’t belong in any cavities or assembly insides. Extrapolating a day’s vapor passage to months, years and several years. But I agree that for an inspector, it is not a ‘defect.’

I think I understand your description, but that is probably not important. What matters is whether your photo is in a space that is conditioned (heated/cooled) on the same thermostat as the upper floor. If both conditioned floors are on the same thermostat (probably entire house on one thermostat), then no issue. This is most common in Colorado. If the photo is in an unconditioned space (i.e. crawlspace) then the boot should be sealed to the floor above. If the photo is in a different zoned area with a separate thermostat from the floor above, then it should be sealed.

Yeah, probably zero. Usually, an incidental or accidental observation. But if it is something that is wrong, then it is a fortuitous observation. An inspector sees a glimmer of light around the duct boot. He/she pauses and asks, “Does this matter?” The answer is in the comments above.

1 Like