Inspection Advice

I agree with you…

2 Likes

Charlotte, NC

1 Like

What I am seeing from the photos is framing for a hip roof. There is nothing that I am seeing that needs to be changed.

The second photo is hard to tell what is going on. I do not think it is a sistered rafter. I am not there, but my immediate thought is that they were off on their space for the roof sheathing and they used it for nailing.

I don’t want to throw an inspector under the bus. However, if I were to note something like that in a report, and a contractor were to charge to say there was nothing wrong, I would expect for you to send me the bill.

4 Likes

Am I overlooking the gusset plates in the photos?

2 Likes

All I’m Seeing are some Hip rafters with blurry scarf joints?

1 Like

There appears to be a slight color change of the lumber in this area. I’m wondering if this is the location of the stated “SPLICE” being referred to? (Large Arrow points to nothing I see of concern). Need a much better photo for detail. Suggest this area is pointed out to the contractor that will be doing the follow-up eval.

Based on your pictures, your inspector may have been a bit over zealous in calling out construction techniques they aren’t familiar with. Many times, inspectors will error on the side of caution in those types of circumstances. Unless there is something else not shown in the pictures, the contractor will likely say it is fine as is. I hope that helps settle your nerves!

2 Likes

Recommend calling the inspector and have a discussion with him/her.
Perhaps he/she would be willing to join the contractor (and you) to discuss the situation on-site?

Remember, we only see a tiny portion of what the inspector see’s on site.
There may well be issues we don’t see in the poor, online pics.
If you have more questions, be sure to take and post quality photos to show us exactly what you need more info on.
Good luck.

4 Likes

For the OP, please let us know what your contractor ends up advising. It would be good information to help other inspectors in the future.

2 Likes

I do. From what I can see, that looks like standard stick-built hip rafter construction. If there were splices, that would perhaps be a concern if not done properly. However, there are no splices that I can discern in the photos.

3 Likes

The LARGE arrow appears to be covering the mating rafter. Note the small area of OSB with no pattern.

If this inspector claims there were no vertical supports, then what’s this? (Green arrow)

Looks like vertical framing from here.

2 Likes

As most everyone else has said there is nothing here to be concerned with. I’m guessing your inspector was not too experienced.

2 Likes

no, it was an ai generated answer that put that in there. no gusset plates on those rafters i could see and it was almost certainly rafters and not trusses. sounds like an inspector who didn’t know how hip roofs were built using rafters. come to think of it, i can’t recall for certain if i’ve ever seen one built with trusses. i haven’t built many hip roofs.

I see this every day.

2 Likes

Your instincts are correct. You have more of what it takes to be a home inspector than your home inspector. You may be a victim of what’s plaguing the home inspection industry, inexperience and lack of training.

There is the possibility that your inspector may have seen something that we cannot see in the photos. But if your contractor confirms what others have already said, let me make a few recommendations.

Get your contractors opinion in writing and send a copy to your inspector. If the contractor is charging you a fee, send the receipt to your inspector. This one’s extreme, but file a complaint with the state licensing board. Post a mediocre review, that will get his attention.

The problem is that if the inspector doesn’t know that he is giving bad advice, he will continue to give bad advice.

2 Likes

Trusses have been the predominate way of building here for decades.

2 Likes

Experience helps.

We’ve been building with trusses (even hips) up here for over 50 years.

7 Likes

I guess AI never told him about hip truss construction.

1 Like

That splice requires a vertical support or an engineered splice design.