Originally Posted By: Peter Seiler This post was automatically imported from our archived forum.
The surface of the brick indicates moisture damage. Like you said, there was no cap on top of the poor chimney. Most likely you will be able to carve the chimney with a butter knife. If so, then the bricks have aged and are not structurally sound anymore. 108 year old bricks turn into dust when they are exposed to constant water flow. Whether a chimney cap save the house depends on further testing.
Sometimes building a new chimney (using modern construction techniques) is cheaper and safer than trying to repair old brick. Further shifting is to be expected, which could cause life-threatening leaks.
Originally Posted By: kmcmahon This post was automatically imported from our archived forum.
There are a couple of things to consider here.
This looks like a basement photo (photo of the chimney starting in the basement), so it’s doubtful it’s a moisture issue that made the crack. Looks more like a settlement crack at the penetration, which is minor.
Is there terracotta flue tile in the chimney? If it’s a double wall chimney then its a minor issue corrected by simply sealing the crack. If the metal fue extends out of the roof, then you’re probably ok.
If it’s a single wall chimney (brick only) then there is more than one issue and will need to be corrected by installing a metal flue up the chimney.