Possible pitting in PVC sewer line

Had a camera put down the sewer for an issue after where the PVC(10 years old) joins up with the terra-cotta. When plumber was going through PVC he noted “pitting” and said it was a sign that the wrong type PVC was installed and could cause an issue of collapse within the next 10 years.

I can’t find any info on this elsewhere, and had another plumber tell me that it’s not an issue.

I’m going to be renting the house out and don’t want any issues with plumbing backing up into the newly finished basement. We are already digging up the street to replace the terra-cotta from new PVC pipe to the main because it is filled with roots. Should we just replace the whole line including the “new PVC” at the same time, or is this a non issue that the one plumber is gouging me for.

Link to pictures and video of PVC:

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1P_oYGxPFLKWYrNesTfFcxAb8s7_cyS_u

nobody could really answer that for you Travis without more information…

2 Likes

If you are renting the house, are you responsible for replacement in your rental/lease agreement? :thinking: :man_shrugging:

As a landlord, I can sympathize. But, I agree with Jim. No one can answer for you without more info.

And, if I had any concerns, and the ground was already dug up mostly…well, I might just finish the job for my own peace of mind. But, that’s me.

3 Likes

I guess my main question is: based on the pictures, does this pipe look ok or does it show signs of degradation in the near future.

I wonder if a past tenant flushed meth lab waste down the toilet.

1 Like

Sorry for confusion. I am owner of home and will be renting out the property. My concern is that tenants could have issue in the future.

Seems to me you answered your own question, unless of course, you’re one of “those” landlords!

Three options:

  1. Do nothing…
  2. Fix only what’s needed now, and keep your fingers crossed for down the road failures…
  3. Be proactive, and make all repairs and upgrades now, while you have full control over the situation!!
1 Like

No, my question is…. Is the “pitting” shown in the drain, a real concern. If I was “one of those”
Landlords I wouldnt be looking for answers. I’m already spending $20k on ripping up the street to solve the other issue. This is a 10yo pipe that shouldn’t have any issues.

Again… IMO, you’ve answered your own question!

One plumber said it was a concern. Another said it wasn’t a concern. My question is what do others think? Is this a problem that should not be happening 10 years into the playing of the pipe, or is this normal and can still expect another 40 years out of the pipe?

I would find a plumbing forum and ask there, if I was you. :man_shrugging:

1 Like

I’ll bet the first plumber was looking for work. PVC pipe will last for generations.

There is no pitting in the pipe. That’s what it looks like coming out of the factory

7 Likes

The PVC looks like a plumbers snake went down the line with a root cutter attachment.

You said the clay portion was full of roots, so the story lines up. The PVC got pitted when the roots were cleared.

I highly doubt it needs to be replaced.

And as far as I know, there is no such thing as wrong PVC. Considering thin wall SDR35, which is thinner than regular PVC, is allowed for sewer lines.

2 Likes

Hello Travis , that plumber is correct, it’s a thinner wall PVC and eventually will fail, unlike schedule 40, which is rated 40+ years. I was an estimator for Roto-Rooter back in the day and scoped a lot of lines.

Depending on the depth it can get up there in replacement price. My rec is to replace as soon as humanly possible. If it collapses, backups are eminent and rodding it out will be impossible unless you hire a jetting service.

Line replacements will require a permit and final inspection by code enforcement. Hope it works out…

So you can tell what schedule pipe that is from the interior? Curious, what DWV pipe is approved that is thinner than schedule 40 PVC?

Yup figured as much :roll_eyes:

2 Likes

As I said, I scoped a lot of lines, so yea, I can tell. As for what’s approved, depends on what’s allowed by code in the area. From the photo @tihle posted it appears to be schedule 30.

Gee, thanks, I guess :roll_eyes:

1 Like

I’ve only been a licensed plumber for 38 years. Can you tell me again how this is schedule 30 PVC pipe? By the way, I’ve never seen schedule 30 used as DWV pipe anywhere in the three jurisdictions I’ve been licensed in.

1 Like

Roto-rooter is the company that told me that this was an issue. I’m wondering if they are being trained incorrectly or they have a secret no one else knows?

1 Like

Ask yourself one question. Does Roto-Rooter have a vested interest in their statement?

The reason people hire us is we are a third-party inspector. We don’t perform repairs on anything that we inspect.

There is nothing in your video that’s unusual.

2 Likes