SEVERE COIL DEGRADATION and MOLD

Carrier HVAC system installed in new house built in 2015
Located in SC near the GA line
Second floor/attic space insulated with spray foam
Furnace located in attic with spray foam directly above
There is a door between furnace area and second-floor hallway
Returns (2) located in finished hallway outside furnace area
One furnace - two zones with automatic dampers
At five years, had evaporator coil replaced because it was under warranty and was starting to corrode
It was not severe corrosion but replaced as preventive measure
Technician said it would be a new aluminum coil and would not rust
System under 2x yearly maintenance for most of the last seven years
At most recent service visit technician found severe deterioration of coil and mold
Fins are breaking off and getting into the drain line
Coil is just over five years old
HVAC company’s engineer came out and suggested corrosion due to off-gassing of spray foam
His suggestion is to replace whole system and to include a dehumidifier and an air cleaner
Sought opinions from two other HVAC companies
One suggested a similar course of action
The other suggested feeding the furnace directly with fresh air from outside and a dehumidifier
Furnace currently has no fresh air feed
Wanting to solve the problem rather than just keep replacing things, sought opinion of local home inspector
He felt off-gassing was unlikely after 10 years
He said he never recommends a dehumidifier in an attic and if it is off-gassing, an air cleaner won’t help
He was in touch with a spray foam expert who recommended cutting out a piece and having it tested
The inspector thought the expert was helping us somewhat informally and cooperatively
Instead a long (maybe 9 pages) agreement was sent with a detailed and expensive fee chart
It was going to be thousands and the local inspector suggested not moving forward with that plan
Photos are attached showing damage, mold and general furnace area - UPDATE: I can only post one photo as a new user so posting the coil photo
Looking for any comments, observations, suggestions on how to proceed at this point
Thank you in advance for any assistance!

Lots of things to consider here with the information provided. Do you have or can you get a picture further away of the overall attic area in question?

Here is what I found on the web that can cause the problems you mentioned, and some have been discussed in your post.
The rusting of evaporator coils is primarily caused by humidity and condensation , VOCs , and galvanic corrosion . Here’s a detailed breakdown of these causes:


2


2


1


Prevention strategies include controlling moisture and chemical exposure, regular maintenance, and installing whole-house air cleaners to filter out airborne VOCs. If corrosion has caused a refrigerant leak, replacement of the evaporator coil is required, as repairing pinhole leaks is difficult and unreliable.


1

4 Likes

Here is a good read on your topic, which may help with a solution.

Located in SC near the GA line
This is especially prevalent in coastal areas with high salt content in the air, creating a highly conductive environment that accelerates aluminum fin corrosion.
The area you maybe in may also play a part and is discussed in the article below.

Coil Corrosion: Causes, Prevention, and Solutions - Welltech Cooling Systems

1 Like

I agree, that would be helpful. My concerns would be how well sealed and/or insulated are the joints of the return air. I bet it gets very in the attic of a southern Georgia/North Florida home and some of that hot humid air could getting pulled into the return air and causing excessive condensation. I also see some rust below where the evap coil drain pan is. That could suggest that the drain is either clogged or cannot handle that amount of condensation. Lack of airflow across the evaporator coil would be another concern.

If I encountered this in an inspection, I would refer it out to an HVAC and/or ventilation specialist. The one that comes to mind that is active in the forum is @dandersen

3 Likes

I agree with it not being off-gassing. I think you have a humidity problem in a tight house in a humid climate. Mold tells a story that needs to be heard.

4 Likes

One would think that they would have seen this coming before now!

2 Likes

Was the trap for the condensate line properly installed? Many Carrier units have a warning/instruction label directly on the AHU describing the trap placement/requirements.

This is a common installation defect in this area.

There are other specific instructions as well that are commonly not followed.

4 Likes

Testing for what, the presence of foam?

I’ve seen a bunch of A/C coils with that kind of corrosion in homes that don’t have any foam, sprayed-on or otherwise.

3 Likes

Hi - Thanks for the reply and to your points:

I will post some photos of the overall attic in my replies here but I’m only allowed to include one photo per post as a guest, so please check the whole thread for other photos.

I have an iFLO installed that has worked well and has resulted in no drain line clogs. No water pools in the pan. The general attic and upstairs area has not been unduly humid.

One of the HVAC people who assessed the situation said he beileves it is formicary corrosion due to the off-gassing of the spray foam. The two home inspectors who weighed in on this doubted that there would be off-gassing after 10 years but allowed for the possibility. I’ll include a close-up photo of the spray foam. There are little pinholes in many spots and there was some speculation that this was the result of a careless application of the spray foam liquids. One inspector theorized that moisture gets sucked up to the underside of the roof through these pinholes and when it’s a sunny day and the roof heats up and the moisture evaporates, then VOC particles are released. They then react with the coil causing the degradation.

No one offered galvanic corrosion as a possible cause.

The prevention strategies have generally been included in the three estimates I got, including a dehumidifier and a heavy-duty air cleaner. That said, the inspector that visited on-site said he never recommends a dehumidifier in an attic and that if it is off-gassing, then the air purifiers/cleaners will not make much of a difference.

The photo attached to this reply shows the general area of the furnace with the spray foam above.

Thanks for providing this resource!

I’m also attaching a photo of the moldy area - again, I can only include one photo per post so spreading them out through the thread.

Haven’t seen the drain clogged especially with the iFLO.

Agree with your point on “should have seen this coming!”

Attaching a photo of the spray foam with the many pinholes. Literally in the next opening, the foam has none of these. Across the entire attic, the foam is like this: some areas have no pinholes, while others do.

Good points! Not sure if they followed these directions or not when installed.

Here is a photo of the spray foam that is in the next opening to the other photo I posted with the pinholes in the foam but this is virtually free of pinholes.

The plan was to test the foam itself, to see if it could be identified as a source for the contaminants.

I believe your thoughts about the sealing of joints could be a part of the problem.

In the attached photo, you can see a whole seam where the mastic is no longer holding a seal. There is also a similar lack of seal around one of the flexible ducts that I believe is the return air duct.

1 Like

This article is very informative - thanks for posting the link!

It actually helps support the elements of one of the HVAC estimates which proposes a heavy-duty, standalone air purification system and a dehumidifier.

1 Like

This is what I think is going on, but not the only problem!

1 Like


They are there. spray foam shows cracking, any Idea why the foam was spray painted? Maybe a mold inhibitor?

The “pinholes” look like burst bubbles to me…like maybe a foam mixture issue or some such.

I am not familiar enough with the mixing of ingredients for foam insulation to know for sure. But those pinholes look like tiny burst bubbles to me.

3 Likes

Well, to start with your barking up the wrong tree in many areas here.

HVAC evaporator coils are designed to be operated in wet conditions. The coil operates at 40° f during the air conditioning and will condense water anytime it’s in operation. A dehumidifier is a ridiculous consideration. The air conditioner IS a dehumidifier. Other considerations like leaks into the return causing excessive moisture is also incorrect because we want as much indoor air to get into the air conditioner to be dehumidified and sent down the plumbing pipe as possible. The change of state between a water vapor and a liquid water is the primary BTU absorption rate that the system can provide. When you change that, the system doesn’t operate as design.

From the picture I see of your coil the side plate of the coil is the only thing corroding. It’s made out of galvanized metal. It has no significant purpose other than to keep the air from leaking around the coils ( bypass Factor).
The Coil Tubing that makes up the coil is aluminum, not copper. I do not see anything reacting to the aluminum.

My first consideration would be to look for contaminants in the house that are passing through the indoor air into the HVAC system.
Galvanized metal in an HVAC system is essentially steel coated in a protective layer of zinc. While zinc is great at fighting off standard rust, it is surprisingly sensitive to certain chemical environments found in modern homes and industrial spaces.
​If your evaporator coil is showing signs of premature corrosion one of the following culprits is likely to blame:

​1. Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs)
​The most common indoor air contaminants that eat away at galvanized coatings are organic acids. These are often off-gassed from common household materials.
• ​Formic Acid: Often sourced from cosmetics, disinfectants, and even some wood finishes.
• ​Acetic Acid: This is the primary component of vinegar. It is frequently found in cleaning supplies, silicone sealants, and plywood/particle board adhesives.
• ​The Result: When these acids mix with moisture (condensation) on the coil, they create a corrosive environment that leads to Formicary Corrosion.
​2. Formisides and Chlorinated Compounds
​Halogens are “zinc-killers.” If you have these in your air, the galvanized coating won’t last long.
• ​Chlorine/Bleach: Even the fumes from nearby laundry rooms or indoor pools can drift into the HVAC intake.
• ​Fluorocarbons: Found in some aerosol sprays and refrigerants.
• ​Salt Air: If you live near the coast, sodium chloride in the air is a major driver of galvanic corrosion.
​3. Sulfur-Based Gases
​Sulfur reacts aggressively with zinc and copper.
• ​Hydrogen Sulfide (H_2S): Often associated with sewer gas or “off-gassing” from certain types of defective drywall (notably the “Chinese Drywall” issues seen in previous years).
• ​Sulfur Dioxide: Common in industrial areas or homes with unvented combustion appliances.
​4. High Alkalinity or Acidity (pH Extremes)
​Zinc is “amphoteric,” meaning it corrodes in both highly acidic and highly alkaline environments.
• ​Cleaning Chemicals: Using a coil cleaner that is too acidic (HF-based) or too alkaline (sodium hydroxide-based) without thoroughly rinsing it off will strip the galvanized layer instantly.

Someone mentioned about you being close to the ocean. Salt will corrode with galvanized metals. Very often this corrosion is a white powdery substance, not the reddish brown rust you are seeing. Something is reacting with the plating of the galvanized metal. This is what you need to be looking for inside the house. An air filtering system will not remove these chemicals so don’t waste your money. Trying to reduce moisture is ridiculous because that’s what the HVAC system is there for. Trying to treat symptoms of the problem are not going to work you must treat the source of the problem. What comes in contact with the HVAC systems moisture is going to be in the air. So test your air.

I also see a very large amount of rust in the auxiliary drain pan below the system in the attic. This is the result of excessive exterior condensation on the equipment or inadequate condensate drain operation. The system could simply be out of level or you could have a broken pan underneath the coil which may have been broken when it was replaced recently.
Air flow through the unit could be associated with this excessive moisture as well. If you have restricted airflow more liquid will hang around in the unit during the off cycle. Air circulates through the duct system even when it’s turned off through natural convection. I would assume the HVAC guys that were there would have noticed this, but who knows. The home inspectors seem to be the closest by pointing out contaminants in the air.

Someone was talking about aluminum fins on the coil? I don’t see anything about this. Are you losing your fins or is it just somebody talking? Any white powdery substance that you see on aluminum is contaminated air. Red rust that you’re seeing is something reacting to galvanized metal framing. Galvanic corrosion requires electrolysis good this happens between dissimilar metals and is not likely having anything to do with this.

4 Likes

Hi David - Thanks for the commentary and thoughts. Some of this is beyond my pay grade, but I appreciate your opinions about two of the proposed solutions: a dehumidifier and an air cleaner.

Regarding the “culprits” you identify:

  1. VOCs - one of the HVAC contractors sent their engineer to assess and to offer an estimate. He is the one suggesting that the spray foam is still off-gassing and the primary problem. Other people feel like off-gassing would have ceased a long time ago - the spray foam is 11 years old now.

​2) Formisides and Chlorinated Compounds - The laundry room is at the opposite end of the house and there’s just two of us so laundry is done maybe once a week. Bleach is rarely used. While we are relatively near the ocean, it is 27 miles away. Not sure if that’s close enough to affect the system.

  1. Sulfur-Based Gases - The Chinese drywall problem occurred a number of years before the house was built, so I think that unlikely. We’re not near an industrial area and have no unvented combustion appliances.

  2. High Alkalinity or Acidity (pH Extremes) - We haven’t cleaned the coils ourselves but the tech cleans them when perform

ing the 2x year maintenance. I’m assuming they know they right one to use, but that could be a mistake to assume.

I totally agree that we want to identify the source of the problem - not merely treat the symptoms and have the coil fail prematurely again. I also wonder if there is any health risk associated with what might be in the air.

To at least get an insight into air quality, I purchased an AirThings monitor. It’s been monitoring for about a month now and all measured elements come back in normal or below normal ranges. I understand this is not laboratory-quality testing but merely a tool to perhaps identify something that was way out of range while we try to work through a solution. At this point, it probably makes sense to get a professional air quality test.

We are losing fins from the coil. If you even touch the fins lightly, they fall off. Some are falling into the drain line. I’ll post two photos but I’m limited to one here so I’ll post another separately,

Thanks!