Too complicated for me. I always confirm motor access and ground fault protection. Shouldn’t that suffice?
Absolutely not. Proper bonding is a very important life-safety issue. From a safety standpoint, I’d be way more concerned about bonding before I’d worry about motor access. Sounds like it’s time for Paul to make another 5-minute video to go over checking for the presence of proper whirlpool tub/hot tub/pool bonding. This is the sort of stuff that gets people injured when it’s not present. Maybe it’s something that’s not even in your SOP? That aside, it’s still important.
Not sure what you mean by that comment.
There are some who feel that if the house plumbing is metallic, the motor should be bonded to it. So if the tub is all plastic, and the house piping is copper, would the installer be required to bond to the piping inside the wall? (The house plumbing is not connected to the circulating parts of the tub.) I am not trying to test anyone, I am looking for clarification myself on the subject.
And what about metallic drain piping? It is in direct contact with the circulating water.
There are also some who believe the motor should be bonded all the way back to the panel, in addition to the grounding conductor for the motor. This I know is wrong.
The goal with all this tub bonding stuff is to get all the metal that you can touch at the same time, while you’re either using or servicing the tub, at the same potential. If it’s metal, and it’s connected to the tub by some means, or associated with the tub, bond it all together. Metallic water supply lines and metallic drain lines certainly qualify. Little isolated pieces like metal trim rings and such don’t count, however. If you have copper water lines serving the tub (for instance) and the factory circulation piping on the tub is plastic, you still bond those copper water lines to all the other metal stuff and the lug on the motor (if any).
The metallic water piping is already required to be bonded to the service equipment, therefore, any connection to the metallic water-supply lines creates a “bond all the way back to the panel.”
The systems/components are either bonded, or they are not bonded.
I hear this often from inspectors and even electricians. The phrase “bonding back to the panel” infers (to me anyway) that one does not understand bonding.
That is what I meant by stating some people erroneously think that “bonding” is something that goes to the panel, like “grounding”. I have been called out on a buyers request resulting from a home inspection to “bond” jacuzzi motors when there was nothing to bond them to. I presumed the HI intended for me to “bond” it to the electrical service 60 feet away.
Marc, although I agree bonding the supply piping is a great idea, I don’t see it as a code requirement. Are you speaking from a code requirement or from opinion?
680.74 “All metal piping systems and all grounded metal parts in contact with the circulating water shall be bonded…”
I don’t see the supply piping in contact with the circulating water.
Yes. Break that section down a bit like this:
1)All metal piping systems
-and-
2)All grounded metal parts in contact with circulating water
-shall be bonded…
They did change the wording a bit from 2003 to 2005, but the intent is still the same.
dupliate
I guess I don’t read it that way Marc. I think it says the metal piping needs to be bonded only if it is in contact with the circulating water. If they meant otherwise, they would not just say “all metal piping” without something like “within 5 feet etc”. Instead they say “in contact with the circulating water”
In the 02 code it says “metal piping associated with the tub”. Again, I see this as meaning piping that is part of the tub, not part of the dwelling.
I will bring this question to my next IAEI meeting on Sept 13 and see what the consensus is.
Again, I totally agree it is a good idea and I would always do it when possible, but I don’t see the wording requiring it.
Regards…Brian
I’ve been hunting the '05 ROP on that, and can’t seem to find it. The intent was more clear in the ROP. If you only bond the motor to the heater, for instance, and not the cold water line, you can still have potentially one heck of a potential difference between the water and the metal spiggot or spout. Particularly with the mineralized preperations people are so fond of using in bath tubs.
Mike’s picture is good. It’s right from the IAEI, and shows proper bonding, in my opinion. Admittedly, it may be a pre-'05 picture.
Sounds like a GOOD project…ya think anyone would watch it?
Excellent info all, thankyou.
Great picture Mike.
Only if your ride in on your motorbike during the first scene.
The agent sent this to me today.
Spa Bonding.pdf (24.9 KB)
Looks like someone spent eighty-bucks for a sparky that doesn’t know the difference between “bonding” and “grounding.”
What makes you say that Jeff, with so little information? He said it was a stand alone motor. I had a call for the same thing, the motor was outside the house with nothing to bond it to. All the piping was plastic, outside and inside. I think the HI thought it should have a ground rod or something.
Speculation mostly 8)
That just looked like a response I got from an electrician after I repeatedly told him that the pool equipment needed to be “bonded.” He kept telling me it was already “grounded,” but he would add a ground rod if that would make me happy :roll:
I sent him a copy of Article 680 of the CEC. . .
