Headwall Flashing/Vent Leakage

This isn’t so much inspection-related but I help a condo complex here on Maui with their building. We’re doing some post mortem after the HUGE storms that came through a couple weeks ago. Enough water leaked in that part of the sheetrock ceiling directly below the flashing caved in.

For a little context, the property is ocean-front and normally doesn’t face the main island winds but when they do shift, the wind and rain come right at the face of the building (called a “Kona Low” here on Maui). Anyway, the rain was around 2” per hour at times, accompanied by 70MPH winds. Roof is around a 4:12 so not super steep and not a ton of gravity pull on the water running off. The vent holding the flashing off the roof isn’t ideal but I don’t see an easy alternative (maybe some of you Florida guys can advise something?).

I guess my question is, do you all agree this is a likely point of water entry? “This” being wind-driven rain back up under the flashing and through the vent.

The AOAO (what HOAs are called here) is likely going to want to “fix” something and I’m thinking of telling them it’s just the way it is. Buildings are only so watertight. People here are saying this was a 50-year storm. Basically, I lean towards advising doing nothing since it’s never been a problem before and we have had plenty of big storms… just not this big. Fwiw, with the drywall removed, everything down to the framing is very accessible inside and will get mold-treated/repaired.

Aside from this flashing point, the entire front wall saw some pretty major water intrusion and most of the drywall is going to be removed to investigate and repair.

Just thinking out loud and welcome any opinions.

1 Like

Buildings need to vent.

Maybe stuff that gap with some slightly larger backer rod before the next 50 year storm.

2 Likes

Morning, Matt. Hope to find you well.

That headwall and corner flashing should have been identified as deficient, suspect.

No anger but you might reread the start of my OP….. This isn’t inspection-related. This is a building I have an interest in that I advise maintenance and repairs for. I’ve never laid eyes on the flashing before yesterday so there is no, “should have done a long time ago.” And I’m not looking to pass the buck for “further evaluation.” I am the further evaluation to a large extent. I know the concept of actually figuring something out is lost in today’s inspection world but I’m giving it a try here. Hence, my asking you folks that I trust.

Did you really read my OP? The flashing sits off the roof due to a vent. Not a previous flashing that wasn’t removed.

A moisture meter? Thanks but not really needed when water is pouring in and has collapsed the ceiling in the room below.

I appreciate any an all help along with yours but your tone sucks with condescending “should have” and “simple”…. like every keyboard cowboy. I might suggest you fully read and comprehend posts before mounting your horse.

6 Likes

Sorry Matt.
Lots there, there.

i would ask if the vent is really necessary in that location or if it has to be that type of vent. without seeing anything under it or around it, that’s where i would look first. if it has to stay there, i’d think larry has a great idea with the foam backer. just a guess though.

2 Likes

“One-off” weather events, like the one you described, can wreak havoc on even the best components that were installed as specified or required.
I have seen plenty of off-ridge or box vents leak like crazy during big storms that produce high winds, torrential downpours and sideways rain, and yet never leak 99.9% of the time.

I haven’t researched that type of vent you show, maybe someone manufactures a version with an upturned baffle or some similar attempt to limit water entry in the wrong direction.

4 Likes

Folks around here stuff pool noodles into off-ridge attic vents during high wind storm events to help negate wind driven rain.

3 Likes

I pondered this while sleeping last night. Backer rod is closed cell foam.

I remember they modified ridge vents and manufactured them with foam in them to prevent rain and snow moisture from blowing in, which was a problem for ridge vents of that era, while still allowing it to vent hot, moist air. That was open cell foam.

So, maybe place some open cell foam in the opening to cut down on water entry but allow it to continue to vent.

I bet that would work pretty well if the water was coming in at that vent area.

2 Likes

Just had a client a couple weeks ago tell me a story about his friend with upper east coast ocean front property. He got a “deal” on some quality windows direct from the factory during his build. Long story short the wall of windows suffered moisture intrusions during Nor’easter’s. After finally tearing out the drywall they found it was the windows failing.

When the manufacturer was consulted, they explained he should have told them the windows were intended for ocean front property, that the windows he purchased were not designed for that kind of exposure.

Anyway, my WAG is the windows (along with the vent). The remedy may involve tearing out the wall cladding as well.

Looking forward to what the (destructive) further evaluation reveals.

3 Likes

Great post, Matt. I don’t have any answers, but I appreciate the input posted by the Florida and coastal guys and will follow this thread to learn about this extreme weather solution. I’m glad you and your family are safe from the storm.

4 Likes

Yeah, I’m actually dealing with two separate issues - flooding and storm water entry. I’ve been involved with this building for close to 10 years and seen it go through several floods and weather events. The 1972 stucco is actually a damn good water barrier when flooding occurs around the building but you are right that some it might have to come down on the ocean-facing wall. Especially around the windows..

We had a bad storm back in 2021 and got about 18-24” of water around the building and lots of leakage inside. Drywall, etc. was stripped from all of the perimeter walls and I didn’t find any clear water entry points in the stucco. It all came in the front doors, slider doors and the numerous low windows (yeah, not the greatest design for a flood-prone building).

Since that storm they put in flood barriers at the entry to the parking lot that go up temporarily and they were VERY effective and cutting down the water entry. Another benefit no one saw coming was they have a filtering effect. Maui has a bunch of very fine sediment that gets washed around during floods and it all just piled against the uphill side. The water that did get in the units this time was mostly clear..

We also erected temporary barriers in front of the entry doors that consist of C-channel aluminum that sits in the door frames permanently with 3/4” plywood panels with rubber stripping on the bottom that slide into place. I built and installed those and am very pleased at how they helped. I had hoped to never get to find out if they worked but the weather-gods had other plans.

I was talking to the AOAP president and remarked that this storm was 4X as bad as the one in 2021 and we had 1/4 the damage. IIRC, the one back then was a $1,000,000+ FEMA claim.

With all the things they’ve done, we fared better than any of the nearby buildings.

Every time we have a storm we all get together and see what/where failed and attack it. Next on the list I’m advising them to just cover the lower windows with siding. They offer very little in the way of light and are non-opening. With that done the only real opening left will be the sliders. Door barriers like I did at the front doors won’t work due to the width and lack of a jamb to mount C-channel to. Anyone have ideas?

Thanks for all the input everyone.

2 Likes

This or something similar may be an option…

There are other similar products too.

During Irma I used what I had on hand… plywood w/screws to cover the windows. I used the last two pieces to cover the bottoms of the the front and back doors (you could still access the door knobs and open the doors to enter/exit). I caulked around the bottom of the openings before fastening the plywood. When we returned there was a 12" waterline on the back of the house and a 6" waterline on the front and fish swimming in the pool. It worked, we got less than an inch of water in the house. Still a pain in the ash, but faired way better than all the neighbors who ended up tearing out 2’ of drywall throughout.
The house was a 60’s flat, frame construction, at some point over the years they applied a thick coat of stucco. (I think to hold the place up due to the extensive termite damage).
Good luck.

1 Like

Hey Matt - Thanks for sharing. Do you know what type of stucco system it is? Is it a direct applied / one-coat system? Or does it have a drainage plane behind it of some sort?

I could see that flashing being a type of vent if there were a drainage plane behind the stucco. However, if not, I don’t think you would need a vent there and then flashing and counter flashing would be appropriate.

You might also consider the flashing above the window. Sometimes when you take off old stucco you can really see that the window flashing has leaked a lot. It has decent coverage with the soffit above, but maybe wind could drive water up there too.

Heavy wind-driven rain can really find its way through walls and roofs.

Nice post.

1 Like

Everywhere the walls have been opened up it’s just tarpaper and no drainage screen anywhere on the outside that I’ve ever seen.. Here are a couple pictures from the 2021 event when we took on much more water inside and the walls were more opened up.

1 Like

Hey Matt - Thanks for sharing the pictures.

Here is a detail from Stucco Manufactures Association

Maybe your flashing with a gap is tied to the felt paper and is intended to serve as a weep opening.

It also probably led to your water infiltration issue when you had heavy rain with driving winds.

If you had any damaged roof shingles, it would be interesting to tear the roofing back and see how they handled the transition with the felt paper when they installed the stucco.

Maybe you could get away with no weep transition at the roof level if you were to reroof this and provide new flashing in the future?

I don’t know if there would be a practical way to seal it up in advance of a storm and then remove afterwards.

I’m curious what you’re thinking.

Thanks for sharing everything.

Too obvious to be the problem, but….what is going on here?

That’s the bottom of a sloped wall to roof seam with your arrows right at the lowermost step-flashing piece.

The roof held up great, thankfully. Thanks for the stucco info…. I like some of the ideas about filling the opening when a storm is coming. Although, this was the first time I’m aware of that water came in there. Might just fall into the category of “stuff happens.” (when there’s 70MPH wind and 2” rain/hour, that is). :slight_smile:

1 Like

Thanks Matt. I recently inspected a hotel with stucco cladding. Fenestration has been a chronic problem since the last major storm.

Also, how necessary is that vent? It is relatively small roof.

1 Like

Are there any options to replace with a different type, if it’s absolutely necessary?

2 Likes