This is where we are going to disagree.
There is no universe where a nuclear Iran is a good thing. Every president has kicked this can of manure to the next president. Finally…finally, we do something about this malignancy that has been spreading in the middle east for years. There was never going to a time to deal with Iran that wouldn’t be painful, but in the last twenty or so years, this is arguably the best time to finally remove this tumor. The question is, can we completely remove it? Though history says “Unlikely,” does that mean we should just throw up our hands and say “Que sera, sera?”
Honestly Robert, that is head-in-the-sand thinking. Iran has been killing Americans for years. If you don’t think attacks by their proxies aren’t Iranian, you just aren’t paying attention. We just had a conviction of a would-be assassin funded directly by Iran. Most Democrats including Kamala, called Iran a direct threat until Trump moved on them.
There are so many positives by taking down the Iranian regime that it’s hard to compare the anemic negatives. Even if another anti-American regime takes over, which is likely, they will be so degraded that it should be many, many years if ever, they become a threat to us or their neighbors.
One of the biggest but rarely considered positives, is the effect this operation is having on China. China has been moving aggressively to position itself to be the dominant power on earth. If that is a positive in your view, once again we have 180 degree opposed opinions. There’s no world where I want China dictating anything to us. Venezuela and now, Iran has sobered the China leaders who thought they were on a roll toward global domination. In my world, that’s a good thing.
There’s certainly a possibility that we or Trump get stupid. Bush got stupid. Clinton kicked the can. Whether Obama was stupid or just an American hater is fun debate, but not so debatable that he piled stupid on top of Bush’s stupid. Biden…was Biden. A new description for being stupid, is “Going Biden.” Maybe we’ll look back and lament that Trump shoulda-woulda done this or that, but with what we knew and know at this moment, this looks like a triumphant game-changer-for-the-best move.
On the flip side, it’s good to have contrarians to consider all sides of the arguments. No matter the topic, there are always opposite views.