Shingles over or under flashing?

Aren’t there any homeowners out there that have a sense of logic?

Un-freakin-believable…

Here’s one from today.

063009 266.JPG

Nice touch with the keyway above the pipe collar. Could you see the top of the collar in the keyway? I’m sure it doesn’t extend that far up. The chimney is no better, and roof is awfully wavy.