This flashing has about a 3/4" gap between it and the shingles. The disclosure indicates the roof is 17 years old. House is about 1834 with log roofing spaced about 4’ apart.
There were no indications inside the house of walls moving or ceilings sagging or in the attic of the rafters spreading.
A good diagram with the step/base flashing and cap/conterflashing (local term here)…but does the AHJ allow combustibles like “ice and water” barrier to be installed directly on the chimney?? Usually framing/sheathing members require 1/2-2" clearance.
Scott, if you say these shingles were originally in contact with the flashing, then movement is the only feasible explanation. 3/4 of an inch would be hard to see in the attic without a laser beam or string line. Log rafters may have been replaced with the last roof, in which case simple shrinkage could cause a drop in the roofline. Poor notching, gaps at the ridge, rot from leaky flashing?. You have probably called for further evaluation, which is about all you can do in a normal home inspection anyway.
The roof is all log and hand hewn beams with mortise and tenon joints pegged togather. There was one beam about 14’ away that had a check possibly even a split all the way down the middle of the 8" beam. I think this one was too far away to affect the area in question, but I do think the roof has dropped in the last 17 years.
Brian, I think the flashing was a pretty good job, they reflashed when they rebuilt the chimney and daylight was not visible from the attic space (seen that plenty of times).
Anyway, I did call for further evaluation, I just wasn’t comfortable with it.