We want to encourage professionalism and build a community where InterNACHI members help each other. To that end, we’re going to start to be more diligent about enforcing our long-standing guidelines (see link below). We won’t be going overboard, but in general posts that are unprofessional or belittling to other inspectors won’t be tolerated. And we’re also going to do a bit of housekeeping to improve forum search. Let’s make this a great, informative, and fun place for our industry.
Thanks Nick! I have no problem with free speech as long as it is regulated and respectful. It really has gotten somewhat out of hand the past few years and I do believe many members, new and old, will appreciate a little more control and moderation on particular threads and issues.
Hope you can pull it off and do a better job with the forums.
Today I read the guidelines for the first time. I’d encourage you to delete this provision about rudeness for being overly vague:
Be civil. Don’t post anything that a reasonable person would consider offensive, abusive, or hate speech.
Of concern is the fact that what’s labeled not-civil, offensive, abusive or hate speech to one person may be cordial, constructive or polite speech to another person.
It is impossible to have a critical debate without the risk of offending someone.
You cannot inoculate the world against offensive speech, you can only inoculate yourself.
These guidelines will only have teeth when someone decides to be offended.
“Free speech with moderation” is an oxymoron.
If everyone is sick of political post then move them all to a political post category with a warning, a warm blanket, and a binky. Otherwise, every section is the wild wild west.
Does this mean the forum will be going back to the way it was back in the day, with religious and political posts in the NFE section?
And when a thread goes off the rails, as many do, we can request, like we used to be able to, that it be moved to the NFE?
IMO, that would be a good thing for the forum as a whole.
As others have stated, I’m all for freedom of speech, and would be 100% for a ‘off-topic’ type section where the gloves can come off; given that it is members only. (Maybe this already exists, or will?)
I think the direction forward is overall a good move from the standpoint of professionalism alone.
Here’s how I’m looking at it:
There will be those who stumble upon this forum (non-inspectors), who are looking at our community from the outside-in; whether they’re looking for advice or they’re just curious about how InterNACHI inspectors conduct themselves in a public forum.. If all they come across is non-inspection related topics, gloves-off discussions, or emotionally-driven rants, does it give them a positive impression of InterNACHI members? Would they want to work with an InterNACHI inspector the next time they purchase or sell a home?
There is definitely a fine line in the sand though, because while moderation can be good.. over-moderation can be bad. At the end of the day, this forum should be a reflection of the code of ethics & the professionalism we all strive to maintain with our clients.
In my opinion, I don’t think Nick is referring to the political posts. I think he is referring to inspection related topics where the OP, or others with varying viewpoints, are blasted for not asking the question perfectly, not posting exactly the picture some people want, not posting in the exact section some want them to, not using perfect punctuation, grammar, and terminology, not using the search extensively (which the search function is very poor, so I don’t blame people), for asking a question that has been asked before, for not knowing everything about everything, for not having spent as much time as others on the forum, for not being as great of an inspector as others, etc., etc., etc.
We all see it everyday. We all know who the usual suspects are.
This will be interesting to see where it goes! It seems over the past 20 years that every few years this comes up?
For this cycle - Do you think rage baiting posts will be moderated or all together eliminated? Teeing up a topic and thread where you know that 10 or so are go at it back and forth like the just slammed 10 Redbull’s each and it tabulates 1000’s of posts over a few years,IMO, is kinda like giving rats a piece of cheese in a locked cage, it’s hard for them to not wanna take a bite. That’s not really fair.
Or where a group of mods agree where the line is? Or just one mod’s opinion of where the line is?
I feel for ya, truly. Here’s to a better InterNACHI forum!
Ya’ll seem to have forgot this little fact… These forum’s are controlled by a third party vendor…
As long as Internachi continues with this platform, (which it surely will), it will continue to become “woker and woker” every year.
I wonder how many have noticed a potential ‘Discourse’ employee snooping around?
I’ve noticed one so far. Can’t be sure this person actually is, but everything looks ‘fishy’ to me!
This same thing happened the last time we had issues and Nick claimed to take action to get it handled.
Kinda’ curious how many veteran inspector members we’ll lose this time around? There’s not a hell of a lot of us left that bother with the MB anymore.
Just sayin’!